The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
[68] The available evidence indicates that the dolicho-blond race
of northern Europe probably originated in a mutation (from the
Mediterranean as its parent stock?) during the early neolithic period,
that is to say about at the beginning of the neolithic in western
Europe. There is less secure ground for conjecture as to the date
and circumstances under which any one of the other European races
originated, but the date and place of their origin seems to lie outside
of Europe and earlier than the European neolithic period. Unfortunately
there has been little direct or succinct discussion of this matter
among anthropologists hitherto.--Cf. “The Mutation Theory and the Blond
Race,” _Journal of Race Development_, April, 1913.
[69] The Melanesians may be contrasted with the Baltic peoples in
this respect, though the comparison is perhaps rather suggestive
than convincing. The Melanesians are apparently endowed with a very
respectable capacity for workmanship, as regards both insight and
application, and with a relatively high sense of economic expediency.
They are also possessed of an alert and enduring group solidarity.
But they apparently lack that reasonable degree of “humanity” and
congenital tolerance that has on the whole kept the peoples of the
Baltic region from fatal extravagances of cruelty and sustained hatred
between groups. Not that any excess of humanity has marked the course
of culture in North Europe. But it seems at least admissible to say
that mutual hatred, distrust and disparagement falls more readily into
abeyance among these peoples than among the Melanesians; particularly
when and in so far as the material interest of the several groups
visibly suffers from a continued free run of extravagant animosity.
The difference in point of native propensity may not be very marked,
but such degree of it as there is has apparently thrown the balance
in such a way that the Baltic peoples have, technologically, had the
advantage of a wide and relatively easy contact and communication;
whereas the Melanesians have during an equally protracted experience
spent themselves largely on interstitial animosities--Cf. Codrington,
_The Melanesians_; Seligmann, _The Melanesians of British New Guinea_.
[70] These considerations apparently apply with peculiar force to the
blond race, in that the evidence of early times goes to argue that
this stock never lived in isolation from other, rival stocks. It began
presumably as a small minority in a community made up chiefly of a
different racial type, its parent stock, and in an environment at large
in which at least one rival stock was present in force from near the
outset; so that race competition, that is to say competition in terms
of births and deaths, was instant and unremitting. And this competition
the given conditions enforced in terms of group subsistence.
[71] Cf., e. g., Sophus Müller, _Vor Oldtid_, “Stenalderen.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account