The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
But the experience which yields this useful and pseudo-useful knowledge
is got under the impulsion and guidance of one and another of the
instincts with which man is endowed, and takes the shape and color
given it by the instinctive bias in whose service it is acquired. At
the same time, whatever its derivation, the knowledge acquired goes
into the aggregate of information drawn on for the ways and means of
workmanship. Therefore the habits formed in any line of experience,
under the guidance of any given instinctive disposition, will have
their effect on the conduct and aims of the workman in all his work
and play; so that progress in technological matters is by no means an
outcome of the sense of workmanship alone.
It follows that in all their working the human instincts are in this
way incessantly subject to mutual “contamination,” whereby the working
of any one is incidentally affected by the bias and proclivities
inherent in all the rest; and in so far as these current habits and
customs in this way come to reënforce the predispositions comprised
under any one instinct or any given group of instincts, the bias
so accentuated comes to pervade the habits of thought of all the
members of the community and gives a corresponding obliquity to the
technological groundwork of the community. So, for instance, addiction
to magical, superstitious or religious conceptions will necessarily
have its effect on the conceptions and logic employed in technological
theory and practice, and will impair its efficiency by that much. A
people much given to punctilios of rank and respect of persons will
in some degree carry these habitual predilections over into the field
of workmanship and will allow considerations of authenticity, of
personal weight and consequence, to decide questions of technological
expediency; so that ideas which have none but a putative efficiency may
in this way come in for a large share in the state of the industrial
arts. A people whose culture has for any reason taken on a pronounced
coercive (predatory) character, with rigorous class distinctions, an
arbitrary governmental control, formidable gods and an authoritative
priesthood, will have its industrial organisation and its industrial
arts fashioned to meet the demands and the logic of these institutions.
Such an institutional situation exerts a great and pervasive constraint
on the technological scheme in which workmanship takes effect under
its rule, both directly by prescribing the things to do and the time,
place and circumstance of doing them, and indirectly through the habits
of thought induced in the working population living under its rule.
Innovation, the utilisation of newly acquired technological insight, is
greatly hindered by such institutional requirements that are enforced
by other impulses than the sense of workmanship.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account