The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
In the known lower cultures such institutional complications as might
be expected greatly to hinder or deflect the sense of workmanship
are commonly neither large, rigorous nor obvious. Something of the
kind there apparently always is, in the way, for instance, of the
customary prerogatives and perquisites of the older men, as well as
their tutelary oversight of the younger generation and of the common
interests of the group.[18] When this rule of seniority is elaborated
into such set forms as the men’s (secret) societies, with exacting
initiatory ceremonies and class tabus,[19] its effect on workday
life is often very considerable, even though the community may show
little that can fairly be classed as autocracy, chieftainship, or
even aristocratic government. In many or all of these naïve and
early developments of authority, and perhaps especially in those
cultures where the control takes this inchoate form of a customary
“gerontocracy,”[20] its immediate effect is that an abiding sense
of authenticity comes to pervade the routine of daily life, such
as effectually to obstruct all innovation, whether in the ways and
means of work or in the conduct of life more at large. Control by a
gerontocracy appears to reach its best development and to run with the
fullest consistency and effect in communities where an appreciable
degree of predatory exploit is habitual, and the inference is ready,
and at least plausible, that this institution is substantially of a
predatory origin, that the principles (habits of thought) on which it
rests are an outgrowth of pugnacity, self-aggrandisement and fear.
Under favouring conditions of friction and jealousy between groups
these propensities will settle into institutional habits of authority
and deference, and so long as the resultant exercise of control
is vested by custom in the class of elders the direct consequence
is a marked abatement of initiative throughout the community and
a consequent appearance of conservatism and stagnation in its
technological scheme as well as in the customary usages under whose
guidance the community lives.[21] So these instinctive propensities
which have no primary significance in the way of workmanship may come
to count very materially in shaping the group’s technological equipment
of ideas and in deflecting the sense of workmanship from the naïve
pursuit of material efficiency.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account