The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts — John Shaqi
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial artsVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The instinct of workmanship, and the state of industrial arts
Veblen, Thorstein
Industrial arts -- History; Industries -- History; Technology -- History; Workmanship -- History
pressure brought on them by the potter’s hands, and without questioning
the matter of fact that such and so much of manipulation will mix
such and so much of tempering material with the given lot of clay.
The clay is “as wax in her hands;” what comes of it is the product of
her insight and proficiency. Still the pragmatic nature of all these
materials viewed as distinct entities is never to be denied, and in
those respects in which she does not creatively design, manipulate
and construct the work of her hands, its putative self-sufficiency of
existence, meaning and propensity goes on its own recognisances unshorn
and inalienable.
Technological efficiency rests on matter-of-fact knowledge, as
contrasted with knowledge of the traits imputed to external objects in
making acquaintance with them. Therefore every substantial advance in
technological mastery necessarily adds something to this body of opaque
fact, and with every such advance proportionably less of the behaviour
of inanimate things will come to be construed in terms of an imputed
workmanlike or teleological bent. At the same time the imputation of
a teleological meaning or workmanlike bent to the external facts that
are made use of is likely to take a more circumspect, ingenious and
idealised form. Under the circumstances that condition an increasing
technological mastery there is an ever-growing necessity to avoid
conflict between the imputed traits of external objects and those
facts of their behaviour that are constantly in evidence in their
technological use. In so far, therefore, as a simple and immediate
imputation of workmanlike self-direction is seen manifestly to traverse
the facts of daily use its place will be supplied by more shadowy
anthropomorphic agencies that are assumed to carry on their life
and work in some degree of detachment from the material objects in
question, and to these anthropomorphic agencies which so lie obscurely
in the background of the observed facts will be assigned a larger and
larger share of the required initiative and self-direction. For so
alien to mankind, with its instinctive sense of workmanship, is the
mutilation of brute creation into mere opaque matter-of-fact, and
so indefeasibly does the “consciousness of kind” assert itself, that
each successive renunciation of such an imputed bias of workmanship in
concrete objects is sought to be redeemed by pushing the imputation
farther into the background of observed phenomena and running their
putative workmanlike bias in more consummately anthropomorphic terms.
So an animistic conception[30] of things comes presently to supplement,
and in part supplant, the more naïve and immediate imputation of
workmanship, leading up to farther and more elaborate myth-making;
until in the course of elaboration and refinement there may emerge a
monotheistic and providential Creator seated in an infinitely remote
but ubiquitous space of four dimensions.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account