The Intermediate Sex: A Study of Some Transitional Types of Men and Women — John Shaqi
The Intermediate Sex: A Study of Some Transitional Types of Men and WomenCarpenter, Edward
General
The Intermediate Sex: A Study of Some Transitional Types of Men and Women
Carpenter, Edward
Homosexuality; Sex
The meeting of these two currents, of ideal attachment and sexual desire,
constitutes a rather critical period, even when it takes place in the
normal way--_i.e._, later on, and at the matrimonial age. Under the most
favorable conditions a certain conflict occurs in the mind at their
first encounter. But in the modern school this conflict, precipitated
far too soon, and accompanied by an artificial suppression of the nobler
current and a premature hastening of the baser one, ends in simple
disaster to the former. Masters wage war against incontinence, and are
right to do so. But how do they wage it? As said, by grim silence and
fury, by driving the abscess deeper, by covering the drain over, _and_ by
confusing when it comes before them--both in their own minds and those of
the boys--a real attachment with that which they condemn.
Not long ago the headmaster of a large public school coming suddenly out
of his study chanced upon two boys embracing each other in the corridor.
Possibly, and even probably, it was the simple and natural expression of
an unsophisticated attachment. Certainly, it was nothing that in itself
could be said to be either right or wrong. What did he do? He haled the
two boys into his study, gave them a long lecture on the nefariousness of
their conduct, with copious hints that he knew _what such things meant_,
and _what they led to_, and ended by punishing both condignly. Could
anything be more foolish? If their friendship was clean and natural,
the master was only trying to make them feel that it was unclean and
unnatural, and that a lovely and honorable thing was disgraceful; if the
act was--which at least is improbable--a mere signal of lust--even then
the best thing would have been to assume that it was honorable, and by
talking to the boys, either together or separately, to try and inspire
them with a better ideal; while if, between these positions, the master
really thought the affection though honorable would lead to things
undesirable, then, plainly, to punish the two was only to cement their
love for each other, to give them a strong reason for concealing it, and
to hasten its onward course. Yet every one knows that this is the _kind_
of way in which the subject is treated in schools. It is the method of
despair. And masters (perhaps not unnaturally) finding that they have
not the time which would be needed for personal dealing with each boy,
nor the forces at their command by which they might hope to introduce
new ideals of life and conduct into their little community, and feeling
thus utterly unable to cope with the situation, allow themselves to drift
into a policy of mere silence with regard to it, tempered by outbreaks of
ungoverned and unreasoning severity.
I venture to think that school-masters will never successfully solve the
difficulty until they boldly recognize the two needs in question, and
proceed candidly to give them their proper satisfaction.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account