The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory — John Shaqi
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth TheoryRobertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Religion
The Jesus Problem: A Restatement of the Myth Theory
Robertson, J. M. (John Mackinnon)
Jesus Christ
In the Christian record, the Crucifixion is essentially a
sacrifice. "The essence of the Sacrament is not merely partaking of
a common cup or a common meal, but feasting upon a sacrifice ... and
this was found everywhere among Jews and Gentiles." [43] Thus the term
"Eucharist," which means "thanksgiving" or "thank-offering," applied
in the Teaching of the Twelve Apostles to the kind of sacrament
there indicated, and thence taken by Justin and other Fathers,
is clearly a misnomer for the thing specified in the gospels. Of
the gospel sacrifice, the sacrament is the liturgical and symbolic
application. [44] Or, otherwise, the crucifixion is the fulfilment of
the theory of the sacrament. On the view of the historicity of the
former, or of both, it would be necessary to show why the procedure
set forth in the gospels so closely simulated a human sacrifice; and
this is incidentally attempted in passing by M. Loisy. The scene of
derision by the soldiers, he says, "was perhaps connected with some
pagan festival usage." [45] But this at once admits the entrance of
the myth-theory, which affirms that an immemorial "festival" usage
is indicated. If Jesus was executed to please the Jewish multitude,
as is the view even of the most destructive of the later German
exegetes [46]--why should the execution take a pagan form? M. Loisy,
who had previously accepted as history the narrative of the Entry into
Jerusalem, with the public acclamation of Jesus as "the Son of David,"
is unprepared to believe with the German critic that within a week the
multitude cried "Crucify him!"; and he therefore wholly eliminates
that item from his biographical sketch. He implies, however, that
the doom of Jesus was passed by Pilate to please the priests, which
is equally fatal to the thesis of a pagan festival usage. He accepts,
further, the scene of the Mocking, with no ostensible critical reason,
but presumably in order to establish a history which would explain
the subsequent growth of the cult. In this process the salient episode
of Barabbas is dismissed by him as unhistorical. [47]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account