The Jews in Great Britain: Being a Series of Six Lectures, Delivered in the Liverpool Collegiate Institution, on the Antiquities of the Jews in England. — John Shaqi
The Jews in Great Britain: Being a Series of Six Lectures, Delivered in the Liverpool Collegiate Institution, on the Antiquities of the Jews in England.Margoliouth, Moses
History
The Jews in Great Britain: Being a Series of Six Lectures, Delivered in the Liverpool Collegiate Institution, on the Antiquities of the Jews in England.
Margoliouth, Moses
Jews -- Great Britain -- History
WHEN I had the honour of addressing you from this platform on Tuesday
evening last, I endeavoured to establish, by circumstantial evidence,
the probability that the Jews visited this country at a very early
period of their history. I flatter myself, however, that I have
succeeded in demonstrating that some Jews were certainly in this island
in the very first century of the Christian era. How few, or how many,
is doubtful.
It is not too much, however, to expect that some of your minds, at least,
have been exercised on this important inquiry since we last met together.
It is not at all unlikely that some objections against my arguments
suggested themselves to your minds――objections which may at first sight
seem both plausible and natural. For instance, I know that a question
suggests itself on taking my view of the early introduction of the Jews
into this country――why did not Julius Cæsar make any mention of them in
his history of Britain? I meet it by another question. Did Cæsar omit
nothing else? Read his writings and compare them with the works of later
historians, and then tell me whether his silence on the existence of
the Jews in this country furnishes any argument against their having
really been here. If indeed he omitted nothing else but the Jews, there
would then be some force in the argument, but since we know that Cæsar’s
history of Britain affords us but a bird’s-eye view of the state of the
country in his time, what then is the value of such an argument? Again,
supposing that Cæsar wrote a minute and detailed description of Britain,
would there have been any necessity on his part to mention the existence
of the Jews? Certainly not; he wrote for the benefit of his countrymen,
to give them some information respecting the Britons. The Romans knew
who the Jews were; it would have been a waste of time on Cæsar’s part
to have given them information on a subject they were already acquainted
with. He might as well have described the Roman army; especially since
it is supposed that many Jews accompanied him as soldiers to Britain.
Another argument has been advanced against their establishment in this
country at so early a period, which was――“It is not probable that a
total silence respecting them would have prevailed among the British
writers of those days, had any portion of them been then established
in Britain.” I mention those objections because they are the strongest
which have been produced, and you will find them in the eighth volume of
the “English Archæologia,” page 390.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account