The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy (New Series, No. 46, January 1907) — John Shaqi
The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy (New Series, No. 46, January 1907)Pennsylvania Prison Society
Religion
The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy (New Series, No. 46, January 1907)
Pennsylvania Prison Society
Charities -- Periodicals; Prisons -- Periodicals
“If all the corrective methods that are now stamped with the approval
of public sentiment could be maintained to the best advantage in a
single prison, there would be no need of any central authority. It
could not be contended that a general board would be any wiser in
appointments than the local boards of management. Nor could there be
any larger or more humane interest in the affairs of a particular
prison, than is shown by the supervisors who have only one prison under
their charge. But it would be manifestly impossible, in the larger
States at least, to include in a single establishment all the various
agencies that are needed for the discipline, the training and the
treatment of prisoners; and it is therefore essential that different
places should be provided to furnish opportunities best suited to the
capacities and the needs of the widely differing individuals.
“The managers of one prison cannot command a knowledge of all the
prisons as well as a central board, and if the methods that are now
employed are to be used for the greatest good, and to be made available
for the largest number of offenders, there must be some general
authority to rearrange and reassign prisoners after they have been
committed.
“I have no intention here of proposing that the State should take
absolute control of all the penal institutions, or even that the
authority of all boards of management should be measurably disturbed;
but only that some central board should so far possess authority over
all the penal establishments as to be enabled to make a rearrangement
that would promote efficiency of effort.
“In order to show how such a degree of centrality might be sufficient
for large reforms let me outline briefly what I believe would be the
best method of classification of prisoners if all suitable facilities
could be given by the legislature:
“I would recommend the establishment of one receiving prison for all
persons convicted of serious crimes and sentenced to hard labor; in
this place prisoners would be held under continual observation for
a period long enough to allow the authorities to decide where the
prisoner would apparently be likely to receive the most benefit, or
where he could be kept with the most advantage to the State.
“As accessories to this place I would provide departmental prisons,
in each of which some particular element of instruction or discipline
or treatment should be brought to the highest possible degree of
efficiency, such as schools for the illiterate, the manual-training
school and schools for trade instruction.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account