The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy (New Series, No. 46, January 1907)Pennsylvania Prison Society
Religion
The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy (New Series, No. 46, January 1907)
Pennsylvania Prison Society
Charities -- Periodicals; Prisons -- Periodicals
“Another department should be assigned to those who are mentally weak,
so that they could be put constantly under special guardianship. There
are in the prisons, as we all know, many persons who, while not so far
below the normal intelligence as to warrant the experts in declaring
them to be insane, are nevertheless incapable of performing any useful
work or of taking any benefit from prison agencies. In most States
provision has been made for the removal of prisoners who are actually
insane to an asylum specially provided for that class; but so far
there has been no similar establishment created for the safe detention
of prisoners who are found to be so far deficient in intelligence as
to need the sort of treatment that is given in the schools for the
feeble-minded.
“Another humane department would be a hospital prison, an establishment
that should combine the needed safeguards for custody with all the
essential features for the most scientific and skillful treatment of
the different ailments. To be sure it would be necessary to maintain
a small infirmary in each prison for emergency cases, but all cases
requiring long and continuous treatment would be removed to the
hospital prison.
“The last stage of all in such a plan as I outline should be a prison
where the guardianship over the prisoner would be relaxed by degrees,
so that he could approach his freedom in such a way as to regain some
degree of self-reliance.
“To make the general plan of a classified prison system harmonious
and effective, the particular place of imprisonment should not be
unalterably fixed at the outset. In effect to-day the court in
Massachusetts does not absolutely determine the place of imprisonment.
The central board has the power to make transfers from one prison to
another, with the single exception that no person can be put into the
state prison from another place.
“I have seen in other places, however, many prisoners who manifestly
belonged in the state prison.
“It would be needless to recite cases of inequitable sentences that
show the need of classification. As a type of many others I mention
one instance where, through lack of knowledge of the prisoner’s
antecedents, a justice sentenced to the reformatory a man who had been
six times under imprisonment, including a term in the state prison,
and as far as one human being can judge of another, had shown himself
incapable of amendment or unwilling to accept the means of reformation.
“Information that may be immediately available to the prison
authorities when the prisoner is committed, so that they can assign
him to his fit place, is in most cases lacking when the prisoner is
before the court. The needed adjustment of prisoners I think could be
made by a central authority having all places within its purview, after
conference with the prison officials.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account