The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy (New Series, No. 46, January 1907)Pennsylvania Prison Society
Religion
The Journal of Prison Discipline and Philanthropy (New Series, No. 46, January 1907)
Pennsylvania Prison Society
Charities -- Periodicals; Prisons -- Periodicals
“There is one class of misdemeanants, however, which I would exclude
as a rule from any elaborate prison system, although the place for
their detention might be made one of the departments of the plan I
have described, and that is the large number of persons committed
for drunkenness. Most of these have passed beyond the age when they
would be the best subjects for an industrial reformatory. They have
no criminal instincts, are merely social disturbers, and what the
State does in the way of their correction should be different from the
means employed in the care of criminals. And the persons committed for
drunkenness can be dealt with in a better way than now prevails if they
are drawn into larger groups where fitting employment can be given; and
this arrangement would need the intervention of a central board.
“Under a well-organized and thoroughly equipped system, with such a
degree of centrality as I have indicated, all the beneficent methods of
the prisons would be sustained and strengthened.”
The second address of the evening was by Dr. Frederick Howard Wines,
on “The Prisons of Louisiana.” Residence in the South and an intimate
acquaintance with Southern people and Southern prisons, gave the
utterances of Dr. Wines authoritative value. The prison question in the
South, he said, is almost exclusively a negro question. The greater
proportion of crime in the South is committed by negroes. Hence most of
the prisoners are negroes. The negro prisoner is a distinct problem.
The methods we apply to white prisoners are not applicable to him. The
religion of the negro, for example, is altogether emotional and has
little connection with morality. As to education, the Southern people
do not greatly favor the education of the negro. A partly educated
negro thinks he belongs to a select class and must no longer work. As
to the question of labor, he is not fitted for indoor work, nor wanted
by the industrial classes.
As conditions are in Louisiana, I can think of nothing better than the
large plantations on which the convicts are employed. The barracks
are absolutely clean and sanitary. There are no chains. The guards
are unarmed. After breakfast the prisoners go to the cotton and sugar
fields, accompanied by armed guards and hounds. There are few escapes
and very little punishment. Hospital and physician are provided. All
the convicts are well fed, and at the close of the day’s work all must
take a bath. As the labor is steady it is more profitable than that of
the free man. All the earnings go to the support and improvement of the
prisons and prisoners. The lease system is gone in all the counties
but one. Baton Rouge has the only prison of the old style, with walls,
etc. Camps are now the thing, on plantations. Since the abolition of
the lease system, and the adoption of State control, the health of the
prisoners is much better.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account