The Journal of Speculative Philosophy, Vol. I, Nos. 1-4, 1867Various
Philosophy
The Journal of Speculative Philosophy, Vol. I, Nos. 1-4, 1867
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
In the satisfaction of physical wants the ideal consists, above all, in
the simplicity of the means. Instead of being artificial, factitious,
complex, the latter emanate directly from the activity of man, and
freedom. The heroes of Homer themselves slay the oxen which are to serve
for the feast, and roast them; they forge their arms, and prepare their
couches. This is not, as one might think, a relic of barbarous manners,
something prosaic; but we see, penetrating everywhere the delight of
invention, the pleasure of easy toil and free activity exercised on
material objects. Everything is peculiar to and inherent in his
character, and a means for the hero of revealing the force of his arm
and the skill of his hand; while, in civilized society, these objects
depend on a thousand foreign causes, on a complex adjustment in which
man is converted into a machine subordinated to other machines. Things
have lost their freshness and vitality; they remain inanimate, and are
no longer proper, direct creations of the human person, in which the man
loves to solace and contemplate himself.
A final point relative to the external _form of the ideal_ is that which
concerns the _relation of works of art to the public_, that is to say,
to the nation and epoch for which the artist or the poet composes his
works. Ought the artist, when he treats a subject, to consult, above
all, the spirit, taste and manners of the people whom he addresses, and
conform himself to their ideas? This is the means of exciting interest
in fabulous and imaginary or even historic persons. But then there is a
liability to distort history and tradition.
Ought he, on the other hand, to reproduce with scrupulous exactness the
manners and customs of another time, to give to the facts and the
characters their proper coloring and their original and primitive
costume? This is the problem. Hence arise two schools and two opposite
modes of representation. In the age of Louis XIV., for example, the
Greeks and Romans are conceived in the likeness of Frenchmen. Since
then, by a natural reaction, the contrary tendency has prevailed. Today
the poet must have the knowledge of an archeologist, and possess his
scrupulous exactness, and pay close attention, above all, to local
color, and historic verity has become the principal and essential aim of
art.
Truth here, as always, lies between the two extremes. It is necessary to
maintain, at the same time, the rights of art and these of the public,
to have a proper regard for the spirit of the epoch, and to satisfy the
exigencies of the subject treated. These are the very judicious rules
which the author states upon this delicate point.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account