The Life of Tolstoy: First Fifty Years: Fifth EditionMaude, Aylmer
General
The Life of Tolstoy: First Fifty Years: Fifth Edition
Maude, Aylmer
Tolstoy, Leo, graf, 1828-1910
In our youngest--the third--class, they write what they like.
Besides that, the youngest write out in the evening, one at a
time, sentences they have composed all together. One writes, and
the others whisper among themselves, noting his mistakes, and only
waiting till he has finished, in order to denounce his misplaced
e or his wrongly detached prefix, or sometimes to perpetrate a
blunder of their own. To write correctly and to correct mistakes
made by others, gives them great pleasure. The elder boys seize
every letter they can get hold of, exercising themselves in
the correction of mistakes, and trying with all their might to
write correctly; but they cannot bear grammar or the analysis of
sentences, and in spite of a bias we had for analysis, they only
tolerate it to a very limited extent, falling asleep or evading the
classes.
History on the whole went badly, except such bits of Russian history
as, when told poetically, aroused patriotic feelings. On one memorable
occasion the whole class went wild with excitement and eager interest.
That was when Tolstoy, with a poet's licence, told of the defeat of
Napoleon's invasion of Russia in 1812.
Except in this legendary way, the teaching of history to children is,
in Tolstoy's opinion, useless. The historic sense develops later than
the artistic sense:
In my experience and practice the first germ of interest in
history arises out of contemporary events, sometimes as a result
of participation in them, through political interest, political
opinions, debates, and the reading of newspapers. Consequently the
idea of beginning the teaching of history from present times should
suggest itself to every intelligent teacher.
Of geography as a subject for the education of children, Tolstoy has an
even lower opinion:
In Von Vizin's comedy _The Minor_, when Mitrofánoushka was being
persuaded to learn geography, his mother said: 'Why teach him
all the countries? The coachman will drive him where he may have
to go to.' Nothing more to the point has ever been said against
geography, and all the learned men in the world put together cannot
rebut such an irrefragable argument. I am speaking quite seriously.
What need was there for me to know where the river and town of
Barcelona are situated, when for thirty-three years I have not once
had occasion to use the knowledge? Not even the most picturesque
description of Barcelona and its inhabitants could, I imagine,
conduce to the development of my mental faculties.
In fact, the sweeping conclusion at which Tolstoy arrives is that:
I not only see no use, but I see great harm, in teaching history or
geography before the University is reached.
And he leaves it an open question whether even the University should
concern itself with such subjects.
Drawing was a favourite lesson with the boys; but I must confine myself
to a single extract on that subject:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account