The logic of modern physicsBridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Philosophy
The logic of modern physics
Bridgman, P. W. (Percy Williams)
Physics -- Philosophy
Formally, there is no limit to the process of explanation, because we
can always ask what is the explanation of the elements in terms of which
we have given the last explanation. But the point of view of operations
shows that this is mere formalism which ends only in meaningless jargon,
for we soon arrive at the limit of our experimental knowledge, and
beyond this the operations involved in the concepts of our explanations
become impossible and the concepts become meaningless.
As we extend experimental knowledge and push our explanations further
and further, we see that the explanatory sequence may be terminated in
several possible ways. In the first place, we may never push our
experiments beyond a stage into which the elements with which we are
already familiar do not enter. In this case explanation is very simple:
it involves nothing essentially new, but merely the disentanglement of
complexities. The kinetic theory of gases, in explaining the thermal
properties of a gas in terms of ordinary mechanical properties of the
molecules, suggests such a situation. Or, secondly, our experiments may
bring us into contact with situations novel to us, in which we can
recognize no familiar elements, or at least must recognize that there is
something in addition to the familiar elements. Such a situation
constitutes an explanatory crisis and explanation has to stop by
definition. Or thirdly, we may try to force our explanations into a
predetermined mold, by formally erecting or inventing beyond the range
of present experiment ultimates more or less like elements already
familiar to us, and seek to explain all present experience in terms of
these chosen ultimates.
Leaving for the present the third possibility, which is within our
control to accept or reject, and is a formal matter, it is merely a
question of experimental fact which of the first two possibilities
corresponds to the actual state of affairs. The most perfunctory
examination of the present state of physics shows that we are now facing
the second of these possibilities, and that in the new experimental
facts of relativity, and in all quantum phenomena, we are confronted
with an explanatory crisis. It has often been emphasized that Einstein's
theory of gravitation does not seek at all to give an explanation of
gravitational phenomena, but merely describes and correlates these
phenomena in comparatively simple mathematical language. No more attempt
is made to reduce the gravitational attraction between the earth and the
sun to simple terms than was made by Newton. In the realm of quantum
phenomena it is of course the merest commonplace that our old ideas of
mechanics and electrodynamics have failed, so that it is a matter of the
greatest concern to find how many, or indeed whether any, elements of
the old situations can be carried over into the new.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account