The Logic of Vegetarianism: Essays and DialoguesSalt, Henry S.
Philosophy
The Logic of Vegetarianism: Essays and Dialogues
Salt, Henry S.
Vegetarianism
BON VIVANT: But why are not the brutal drovers punished
for it?
VEGETARIAN: Perhaps because it is not for themselves
that they are driving. Then there is the journey in the
railway-trucks, and we learn on good authority (Report
of the Liverpool S.P.C.A.) that "the animals have
frequently gone twenty to twenty-four hours without food
at the time they are driven on the boats." As for the
delights of the sea-transit, you have read, I suppose,
of what happens in cattle-ships?
BON VIVANT: Well, of course, in stormy weather there may
be accidents——
VEGETARIAN: No, I am speaking of the ordinary scenes of
the cattle traffic, and say nothing of the occasions
(not so rare, either) when the boats come into port with
blood pouring from their scuppers——
BON VIVANT: Thank you, thank you! that is enough!
VEGETARIAN: We find it stated, in the Report of the
Committee of Inquiry into the Irish Cattle Transit, that
"the damage sustained by cattle is very serious, and
that the principal portion of that damage is due to
their treatment during shipment, while on shipboard, and
on debarkation." On landing there is more thrashing and
tail-twisting, another railway journey, and then—the
slaughterman. You have visited a slaughter-house, of
course?
BON VIVANT: No, really, I must protest——
VEGETARIAN: Ah, then it should interest you! The
drover's task accomplished, the butcher's begins.
Yard by yard and foot by foot, with chains fastened
to his horns and sharp goads applied to his flanks,
the struggling animal is dragged into the dark,
blood-stained shed, where he is lucky indeed if he
be killed by the first blow of the pole-axe——
BON VIVANT: Shameful! I do not believe you. It cannot
be.
VEGETARIAN: Then many well-known eye-witnesses must have
strangely perjured themselves. Dr. Dembo, for example,
says: "Cases in which several blows are required are
very frequent. On my first visit to the Deptford
slaughtering yards I found that the number of blows
struck was five and more," and he goes on to describe a
case which he saw in London, when _twelve minutes_
elapsed before the animal——
BON VIVANT: Stop! I will hear no more.
VEGETARIAN: You will hear no more—but will you _eat_
more? It is on _you_, not on the brutal drover or
slaughterman, that the responsibility falls. For this is
the "speedy and painless" way in which animals must be
slaughtered that _you_ may live well.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account