The man in the street: Papers on American topicsNicholson, Meredith
General
The man in the street: Papers on American topics
Nicholson, Meredith
American essays -- 20th century
In the professions and industries, in commercial houses, even on the
farm, the second-rate man is not wanted; but political jobs, high and
low, are everywhere open to him. Everything but the public service
is standardized; politics alone puts a premium upon inferiority. The
greatest emphasis is laid upon the word service in every field but
government. The average American “wants what he wants when he wants
it,” and is proud of his ability to get it. “If it isn’t right, we
make it right,” is a popular business slogan. Hotels whose indifferent
service wins the displeasure of the travelling public are execrated
and blacklisted. On the other hand, I have listened for hours to the
laudation of good hotels, of the efficiency of railroads, of automobile
manufacturers who “give good service.” We have a pride in these things;
we like to relate incidents of our successful “kick” when the berth
that we had reserved by telegraph wasn’t forthcoming and how we “took
it up” with the railroad authorities, and how quickly our wounded
feelings were poulticed. “I guess that won’t happen again on _that_
road!” we chortle. Conversely we make our errands to a city hall or
court-house as few as possible, knowing that the “service,” offered
at the people’s expense is of a different order, and public officials
may not be approached in that confident spirit with which we carry our
needs or complaints to the heads of a private business.
Or, if some favor is to be asked, we brag that we have seen “Jim”
or “Bob” and that he “fixed” it for us. It happens not infrequently
that we want something “fixed” from purely selfish motives--something
that should not be “fixed”--and it gives us a pleasurable sense of our
“influence” to know that, as we have always treated “Jim” or “Bob”
all right, “Jim” or “Bob” cheerfully assists us. We chuckle over the
ease with which he accomplished the fixing where it would have been
impossible for us to effect it through a direct legitimate appeal. Thus
in hundreds of ways a boss, great or small, is able to grant favors
that cost him nothing, thereby blurring the vision of those he places
under obligations to the means by which he gains his power.
In municipal government the second and the third rate man, on down to
a point where differentiations fade to the vanishing point, finds his
greatest hope and security. As first-rate men are not available for the
offices, they fall naturally to the inferior, the incompetent, or the
corrupt. In few cities of a hundred thousand population is a man of
trained ability and recognized fitness ever seriously considered for
the mayoralty. Modern city government, with the broad powers conferred
upon mayors, requires intelligence of the highest order. Usually
without experience in large affairs, and crippled by a well-established
tradition that he must reward party workers and personal friends, the
incumbent surrounds himself with second and third rate men, for whose
blunders the taxpayer meekly pays the bills.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account