The meaning of a liberal educationMartin, Everett Dean
Philosophy
The meaning of a liberal education
Martin, Everett Dean
Education
“Our universities not only do not encourage such men; do not offer
them positions, in which it should be their highest duty to do,
thoroughly, that which they are most capable of doing; but, as far as
possible, university training shuts out of the minds of those among
them, who are subjected to it, the prospect that there is anything in
the world for which they are specially fitted.--Imagine the success
of the attempt to still the intellectual hunger of any of the men I
have mentioned, by putting before him, as the object of existence,
the successful mimicry of the measure of a Greek song, or the roll of
Ciceronian prose!”
Twelve years later Huxley was still waging his contest for the
admission of science to the curricula of school and college against an
opposition the obstinacy of which is a little difficult for us today to
understand.
“For I hold very strongly by two convictions--The first is, that
neither the discipline nor the subject-matter of classical education
is of such direct value to the student of physical science as to
justify the expenditure of valuable time upon either; and the second
is, that for the purpose of attaining real culture, an exclusively
scientific education is at least as effectual as an exclusively
literary education.
“I need hardly point out to you that these opinions, especially the
latter, are diametrically opposed to those of the great majority of
educated Englishmen, influenced as they are by school and university
traditions. In their belief, culture is obtainable only by a liberal
education; and a liberal education is synonymous, not merely with
education and instruction in literature, but in one particular form
of literature, namely, that of Greek and Roman antiquity. They hold
that the man who has learned Latin and Greek, however little, is
educated; while he who is versed in other branches of knowledge,
however deeply, is a more or less respectable specialist, not
admissable into the cultured caste. The stamp of the educated man,
the University degree, is not for him.”
“The representatives of the Humanists, in the nineteenth century,
take their stand upon classical education as the sole avenue to
culture, as firmly as if we were still in the age of Renascence. Yet,
surely, the present intellectual relations of the modern and the
ancient worlds are profoundly different from those which obtained
three centuries ago. Leaving aside the existence of a great and
characteristic modern literature, of modern painting, and, especially
of modern music, there is one feature of the present state of the
civilized world which separates it more widely from the Renascence,
than the Renascence was separated from the middle ages.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account