The meaning of a liberal educationMartin, Everett Dean
Philosophy
The meaning of a liberal education
Martin, Everett Dean
Education
“This distinctive character of our own times lies in the vast and
constantly increasing part which is played by natural knowledge. Not
only is our daily life shaped by it, not only does the prosperity
of millions of men depend upon it, but our whole theory of life has
long been influenced, consciously or unconsciously, by the general
conceptions of the universe, which have been forced upon us by
physical science.”
“The scientist, no longer disposed to remain on the defensive with
the usual apology for science, carries the battle into the opposing
camp and indicts the opposition, with some justice I think, for
its failure even when judged by its own traditional standards of
education.
“There is no great force in the _tu quoque_ argument, or else the
advocates of scientific education might fairly enough retort upon
the modern Humanists that they may be learned specialists, but that
they possess no such sound foundation for a criticism of life as
deserves the name of culture. And, indeed, if we were disposed to be
cruel, we might urge that the Humanists have brought this reproach
upon themselves, not because they are too full of the spirit of the
ancient Greek, but because they lack it.
“The period of the Renascence is commonly called that of the “Revival
of Letters,” as if the influences then brought to bear upon the
mind of Western Europe had been wholly exhausted in the field of
literature. I think it is very commonly forgotten that the revival of
science, effected by the same agency, although less conspicuous, was
not less momentous....
“We cannot know all the best thoughts and sayings of the Greeks
unless we know what they thought about natural phenomena. We cannot
fully apprehend their criticism of life unless we understand
the extent to which that criticism was affected by scientific
conceptions. We falsely pretend to be the inheritors of their
culture, unless we are penetrated, as the best minds among them were,
with an unhesitating faith that the free employment of reason, in
accordance with scientific method, is the sole method of reaching
truth.
“Thus I venture to think that the pretensions of our modern Humanists
to the possession of the monopoly of culture and to the exclusive
inheritance of the spirit of antiquity must be abated, if not
abandoned.”
Huxley was one of the few educators of his time who ought to have seen
clearly that in the education of the ancients there was no conflict
of interest between science and letters; the two were one in the
naturalistic minds of the Greeks. He is aware of the fact that both
science and letters were revived by the Renaissance, but it would seem
that he permits his zeal in the cause of scientific training to force
him at times into a rather one-sided and partisan position.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account