The Middle Kingdom, Volume 1 (of 2): A Survey of the Geography, Government, Literature, Social Life, Arts, and History of the Chinese Empire and its InhabitantsWilliams, S. Wells (Samuel Wells)
History
The Middle Kingdom, Volume 1 (of 2): A Survey of the Geography, Government, Literature, Social Life, Arts, and History of the Chinese Empire and its Inhabitants
Williams, S. Wells (Samuel Wells)
China
All these, except No. 12, are heard in the court dialect, which has
now become the most common mode of writing the names of places and
persons in China. Though foreign authors have employed different
letters, they have all intended to write the same sound; thus _chan_,
_shan_, and _xan_, are only different ways of writing 閂; and _tsse_,
_tsze_, _tsz’_, _𝔷h_, _tzŭ_, and _tzu_, of 字. Such is not the case,
however, with such names as _Macao_, _Hongkong_, _Amoy_, _Whampoa_,
and others along the coast, which are sounded according to the local
patois, and not the court pronunciation--_Ma-ngau_, _Hiangkiang_,
_Hiamun_, _Hwangpu_, etc. Many of the discrepancies seen in the works
of travellers and writers are owing to the fact that each is prone to
follow his own fancy in transliterating foreign names; uniformity is
almost unattainable in this matter. Even, too, in what is called the
court dialect there is a great diversity among educated Chinese, owing
to the traditional way all learn the sounds of the characters. In this
work, and on the map, the sounds are written uniformly according to
the pronunciation given in Morrison’s Dictionary, but not according
to his orthography. Almost every writer upon the Chinese language
seems disposed to propose a new system, and the result is a great
confusion in writing the same name; for example, _eull_, _olr_, _ul_,
_ulh_, _lh_, _urh_, _’rh_, _í_, _e_, _lur_, _nge_, _ngí_, _je_, _jí_,
are different ways of writing the sounds given to a single character.
Amid these discrepancies, both among the Chinese themselves and those
who endeavor to catch their pronunciation, it is almost impossible to
settle upon one mode of writing the names of places. That which seems
to offer the easiest pronunciation has been adopted in this work.
It may, perhaps, be regarded as an unimportant matter, so long as
the place is known, but to one living abroad, and unacquainted with
the language, the discrepancy is a source of great confusion. He is
unable to decide, for instance, whether _Tung-ngan_, _Tungon hien_,
_Tang-oune_, and _Tungao_, refer to the same place or not.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account