The migrations of early culture: A study of the significance of the geographical distribution of the practice of mummification as evidence of the migrations of peoples and the spread of certain customs and beliefsSmith, Grafton Elliot
History
The migrations of early culture: A study of the significance of the geographical distribution of the practice of mummification as evidence of the migrations of peoples and the spread of certain customs and beliefs
Smith, Grafton Elliot
Ethnology; Human beings -- Migrations; Mummies
One of the most carefully-investigated bonds of cultural connection
between the Eastern Mediterranean in Phœnician times and pre-Columbian
America (Tehuantepec) has recently been put on record by Zelia Nuttall
in her memoir on “a curious survival in Mexico of the use of the Purpura
shell-fish for dyeing” (=50=). After a very thorough and critical
analysis of all the facts of this truly remarkable case of transmission
of an extraordinary custom, Mrs. Nuttall justly concludes that “it seems
almost easier to believe that certain elements of an ancient European
culture were at one time, and perhaps once only, actually transmitted
by the traditional small band of ... Mediterranean seafarers, than to
explain how, under totally different conditions of race and climate, the
identical ideas and customs should have arisen” (pp. 383 and 384). Nor
does she leave us in any doubt as to the route taken by the carriers of
this practice. Found in association with it, both in the Old and the New
World, was the use of conch-shell trumpets and pearls. The antiquity of
these usages is proved by their representation in pre-Columbian pictures
or, in the case of the pearls, the finding of actual specimens in graves.
In Phœnician Greek, and later times these shell-trumpets were extensively
used in the Mediterranean: “European travellers have found them in actual
use in East India, Japan and, by the Alfurs, in Ceram, the Papuans of New
Guinea, as well as in the South Sea islands as far as New Zealand,” and
in many places in America (p. 378). “In the Old and the New World alike,
are found, in the same close association, (1) the purple industry and
skill in weaving; (2) the use of pearls and conch-shell trumpets; (3)
the mining, working and trafficking in copper, silver and gold; (4) the
tetrarchial form of government; (5) the conception of ‘Four Elements’;
(6) the cyclical form of calendar. Those scholars who assert that all
of the foregoing must have been developed independently will ever be
confronted by the persistent and unassailable fact that, throughout
America, the aborigines unanimously disclaim all share in their
production and assign their introduction to strangers of superior-culture
from distant and unknown parts” (p. 383).
Many other equally definite proofs might be cited of the transmission of
customs from the Old to the New World, of which the instance reported by
Tylor (=102=) is the classical example[2]; but I know of no other which
has been so critically studied and so fully recorded as Mrs. Nuttall’s
case.
But the difficulty may be raised—as in fact invariably happens when these
subjects come up for discussion—as to the means of transmission. Rivers
has explained what does actually happen in the contact of peoples (=68=)
and how a small group of wanderers bringing the elements of a higher
culture can exert a profound and far-reaching influence upon a large
uncultured population (=64= to =70=).
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account