The mind of primitive man : $b A course of lectures delivered before the Lowell Institute, Boston, Mass., and the National University of Mexico, 1910-1911Boas, Franz
Science
The mind of primitive man : $b A course of lectures delivered before the Lowell Institute, Boston, Mass., and the National University of Mexico, 1910-1911
Boas, Franz
Ethnopsychology; Race
There is another hypothesis which might account for the observed changes
of type. If it were assumed that among the descendants of immigrants
born in America there are an appreciable number who are in reality
children of American fathers, not of their reputed fathers, a general
assimilation by the American type would occur. Socially this condition
is not at all plausible; but, on account of the importance of the
phenomenon that we are discussing, it should be considered. I do not
think that any of the observations that have been made are in favor of
this theory. The changes that occur in the Bohemians who arrive here as
young children, the different directions of the changes in distinct
types, particularly the shortening of the head of Bohemians and of
Italians, do not favor the assumption. Furthermore, if the modifications
were due to race-mixture, the similarity between fathers and
American-born children should be less than the similarity between
fathers and foreign-born children, but there is no indication that this
is the case.
This hypothesis is also shown to be untenable by the comparisons of
fathers and mothers with their own foreign-born children. These
comparisons show that the differences are the same in the case of
fathers and children, and of mothers and children; so that obviously the
same conditions must control the relations between fathers and their
children, and mothers and their children. In other words, the fathers
must be considered as the true fathers of their children.
Earnest advocates of the theory of selection might claim that all these
changes are due to the effects of changes in death-rate among
foreign-born and American-born; that either abroad or here individuals
of certain types are more liable to die, and that thus these changes are
gradually brought about. On the whole, it seems to my mind, the burden
of proof would be entirely on those who claim such a correlation between
head-index, width of face, etc., and death-rate,—a correlation which I
think is highly improbable, and which could be proposed only to sustain
the theory of selection, not on account of any available facts. I grant
the desirability of settling the question by actual observations; but,
until these are available, we may point out that the very suddenness of
the changes after immigration, and the absence of changes due to
selection by mortality among the adult foreign-born, would require such
a complicated adjustment of cause and effect in regard to the
correlation of mortality and bodily form, that the theory would become
improbable on account of its complexity.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account