The mind of primitive man : $b A course of lectures delivered before the Lowell Institute, Boston, Mass., and the National University of Mexico, 1910-1911Boas, Franz
Science
The mind of primitive man : $b A course of lectures delivered before the Lowell Institute, Boston, Mass., and the National University of Mexico, 1910-1911
Boas, Franz
Ethnopsychology; Race
It would be saying too much to claim that all the distinct European
types become the same in America, without mixture, solely by the action
of the new environment. First of all, I have investigated only the
effect of one environment, and there is every reason to believe that a
number of distinct types are developing in America; but we will set
aside this point, and discuss only our New York observations. Although
the long-headed Sicilian becomes more round-headed in New York, the
round-headed Bohemian and Hebrew more long-headed, the approach to a
uniform general type cannot be established, because we do not know yet
how long the changes continue, and whether they would all lead to the
same result. I confess, I do not consider such a result as likely,
because the proof of the plasticity of types does not imply that the
plasticity is unlimited. The history of the British types in America, of
the Dutch in the East Indies, of the Spaniards in South America, favors
the assumption of a strictly limited plasticity. Certainly our
discussion should be based on this more conservative basis until an
unexpectedly wide range of variability of types can be proved. It is one
of the most important problems that arise out of this investigation, to
determine how far the instability or plasticity of types may extend.
Whatever the extent of these bodily changes may be, if we grant the
correctness of our inferences in regard to the plasticity of human
types, we are necessarily led to grant also a great plasticity of the
mental make-up of human types. We have observed that features of the
body which have almost obtained their final form at the time of birth
show modifications of great importance in new surroundings. We have seen
that others which increase during the whole period of growth, and are
therefore subject to the continued effect of the new environment, are
modified even among individuals who arrived here during their childhood.
From these facts we must conclude that the fundamental traits of the
mind, which are closely correlated with the physical condition of the
body, and whose development continues over many years after physical
growth has ceased, are the more subject to far-reaching changes. It is
true that this is a conclusion by inference; but if we have succeeded in
proving changes in the form of the body, the burden of proof will rest
on those who, notwithstanding those changes, continue to claim the
absolute permanence of other forms and functions of the body.
In order to gain a correct understanding of the importance of changes in
the frame of the human body, it seems desirable to view the type of
modern man from a somewhat different standpoint.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account