It need not be thought that the cathartic method did us no good. The
United States, just emerging from the taboos of Queen Victoria, was
in need of hyssop. Some of us, brought up among tables and chairs
having limbs in lieu of legs, were really in a bad way. But Freud has
become much more than a physician. Through books which sell in hundreds
of thousands, he seeks to officiate as a pedagogue, a scientist, a
philosopher and a priest.
Therefore it may not be amiss to enquire into his antecedents and his
character, and then to ask ourselves what his teachings amount to as
theory and how they influence our lives if put into practice.
In order to be perfectly fair, I shall confine myself almost
exclusively to the analysis of a single book, the master-piece into
which he has put his most fully elaborated and carefully worked out
speculations, “The Interpretation of Dreams,” using the third edition
of the authoritative English translation of A. A. Brill.
This work, whatever it may be as psychology, is certainly one of the
greatest autobiographies in existence; for in it Freud not only tells
us his dreams--which alone would tell us nothing--but the incidents
from which he deems the dreams to have sprung, and the thoughts and
memories which his study of the dreams have brought to mind. It is a
method to be recommended for those who wish to stand quite naked before
the world. By the time he has done, not even Rousseau or Benvenuto
Cellini are better revealed.
“When I was six years old,” he writes,[48] “and was receiving my first
instructions from my mother, I was asked to believe that we are made
of earth, and that therefore we must return to earth. But this did not
suit me, and I doubted her teaching. Thereupon my mother rubbed the
palms of her hands together--just as in making dumplings, except that
there was no dough between them--and showed me the blackish scales of
epidermis which were thus rubbed off as a proof that it is earth of
which we are made. My astonishment at this demonstration _ad oculos_
was without limit, and I acquiesced in the idea.”
And so, in maturer years, when he came to dream of a woman rubbing her
hands together, the incident was recalled, and he identifies the dream
woman as one of the Fates!
For once his conclusion is not far-fetched. One of the Fates, indeed!
To speak his own jargon, it may have been from those blackish scales
of epidermis that he received the psychic blow which resulted in his
life-long anti-religious mania. His love of God (he once used to
read Philippson’s Bible, and to dream of the illustrations) was made
ashamed by this ridiculous demonstration _ad oculos_, and forced out
of consciousness. The course of history was turned on a certain famous
occasion by the cackling of a flock of geese. It might have been turned
again by the timely use of a cake of soap upon a maternal epidermis.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account