The Monist, Vol. 2, 1891-1892 : $b A quarterly magazineVarious
Philosophy
The Monist, Vol. 2, 1891-1892 : $b A quarterly magazine
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
Goethe’s philosophical views were strongly influenced by Spinoza yet not
so as if Spinoza had impressed his view upon Goethe. Goethe happened to
read Spinoza’s “Ethics” while still immature in mind and felt himself
powerfully attracted by the spirit of the book. “What I may have read out
of or into that work,” he writes, “I could give no account. Yet I found
a pacification of my passions. A great and free vista upon the sensual
and moral world seemed to open before my eyes. That strange sentence ‘_He
who loves God must not demand of God to love him in return_,’ with all
its premises and conclusions filled all my thoughts. To be unselfish in
everything and most so in love and friendship was my highest delight, my
maxim, my practice, so that the bold expression of later years ‘If I love
thee, it is none of thy business’ came right from my heart. In addition
to this, it must be recognised that the most intimate combinations result
from contraries. The all-pervading calmness of Spinoza contrasted with
my excited aspirations, his mathematical method was a counterpart of
my poetical thoughts and habits.” In Spinoza’s doctrine of necessity
Goethe found comfort concerning man’s dependence upon the outer world
which caused him so much pain. It is probable that the famous sentence
of the liberation from passions through a clear comprehension of them
was very sympathetic to Goethe, for it is a characteristic feature of
his poetry that they were confessions as well as liberations of all that
moved and disturbed him. As soon as Goethe was able to give to himself
a clear account concerning that which had affected his soul and as soon
as he could give a poetical form to it so that it became something
independent and outside of him, he gained, in the sense of Spinoza’s
doctrine of liberation from passions, the peace and liberty of his soul.
Yet Spinoza’s doctrine of necessity was a metaphysical conception.
Goethe transferred it into the domains of practical ethics, thus giving
rise to his idea of resignation. Goethe writes in the beginning of the
sixteenth book of “Wahrheit und Dichtung”: “Our physical as well as our
social life, customs, habits, worldly wisdom, philosophy, religion, even
many incidental events, everything demands of us that we should resign
ourselves. So many things which most intrinsically belong to us we are
not allowed to develop. That of the outer world which we want as a
complement of our nature is taken away and many things which are foreign
to us and disagreeable are thrown upon us. We are deprived of everything
that we have with difficulty acquired, of everything that is friendly and
before we fully comprehend it we find ourselves obliged _to surrender
our very personality_, first piecemeal and finally in its entirety.”
Professor Schneege says that Goethe’s practice of resignation gave him
solace when he felt low-spirited concerning the limits of human willing
and wishing and hoping, and his resignation was as a matter of principle
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account