The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazineVarious
Philosophy
The Monist, Vol. 3, 1892-1893 : $b A quarterly magazine
Various
Philosophy -- Periodicals
Now as a matter of fact there are no two concrete things in the world in
which there cannot be found some sameness. Both somehow affect sentiency;
we say they consist of matter. Both can be measured in size, breadth,
and height: we say, they are extended. Both are at any given moment in a
certain relation to other things: we say, they are in space. Both have a
definite form and consist of one or several special structures (i. e.,
so to say, inside-forms). All things can in some way or other be classed
together under one heading. These samenesses of things go along with
differences, and the degree of sameness in the different things varies
greatly. Whether there is any sameness and difference at all in the
world, cannot be decided _a priori_, but is a problem which can be solved
only on the ground of, first, an _a posteriori_ statement of the facts,
second, a systematical arrangement of the facts. If this is accomplished
we can venture into a methodical investigation as to the nature of the
samenesses as well as the differences that obtain in the universe, and
having arranged them in a system, we can apply _a priori_ this system to
facts with which we are not as yet acquainted.
The many samenesses which are experienced are not purely mental
additions; they are not mere subjective imputations transferred upon
objective existence. They are real; i. e. there are in the objective
things actual features which allow of certain substitutions. A ray of
light awakens in some feeling substance the traces left by former rays of
light; and this reawakening is called memory. The perception of sameness
is the beginning of mind, and it involves the perception of difference as
a natural consequence.
Suppose that the stuff of which the world consists were capable of
acquiring feeling, but there were no samenesses whatever; which would
mean that every smallest piece of the world-stuff were a particular
thing by itself and in every respect unlike every other piece, of a
different material or of no material at all, of different size or of
no size at all, and also possessed of a different number of space
dimensions. In such a world all the impacts made upon a sentient being
would be different; not one would be like the other, and all feelings
would present a chaos without uniformities, worse than the most complex
crazy-quilt. Under such circumstances mind would be impossible: it would
neither originate nor could it develop.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account