The Mormon puzzle, and how to solve it — John Shaqi
The Mormon puzzle, and how to solve itBeers, R. W.
History
The Mormon puzzle, and how to solve it
Beers, R. W.
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints -- Doctrines; Latter Day Saint churches -- Doctrines
A great deal that is said and published about the large amount of funds in
the hands of the Mormon leaders, and the use to which they are put, has
not a scintilla of truth in it, although the persons who publish it by
word or pen, being misinformed, thoroughly believe it themselves. Thus, in
one of the most reliable missionary magazines in our land, in May, 1885,
it was stated on the best authority that the Mormons had a large
corruption fund, and as a sample of the purposes to which it is put by
them, it gave the following instance: "When Bancroft, the historian, was
in Utah recently, he was told that if he would write certain things in his
history of Utah, they would take two hundred and forty complete sets of
his works, which would give him $40,000."
The writer determined to use that statement as _a test case_. He, thinking
that the greatest American historian, George Bancroft, was referred to,
sent him a letter of inquiry as to the truth of the statement, and the
following was his reply:
"1623 H STREET, WASHINGTON, D. C., February 3, 1886.
"_Rev. R. W. Beers, Elkton, Md._
"SIR: Yours of February 2d is received. I am astonished that you
should attribute to me anything so false as that I have been in Utah,
and all that follows. You ought not to have needed to ask anybody
about falsehoods so palpable.
"Very respectfully,
"GEORGE BANCROFT."
But how should any of the great number of people throughout our land who
read the missionary magazine where that statement occurred know that he
had not been in Utah, and that the statement was false?
Then the writer, knowing of another great historian Bancroft, Mr. H. H.
Bancroft, the Pacific coast historian, made the same inquiry of him, and
received the following reply:
"SAN FRANCISCO, February 15, 1886.
"_Rev. R. W. Beers._
"MY DEAR SIR: In answer to your letter of the 8th inst., I would say
that the Mormons never asked me to insert anything in my history of
Utah, and never offered to take any copies of the work.
"Very respectfully,
"H. H. BANCROFT."
The writer then directed an inquiry to the person in Salt Lake City from
whom the statement in the magazine claimed to have been made, and asked
him his authority for his statement. The answer was: "The Bancroft alluded
to by me is H. H. Bancroft, the Pacific coast historian. His agent told me
the Mormons had agreed to take two hundred and forty sets of his complete
works in thirty-eight volumes, the gross amount of which (not the net
amount) would be about $40,000, if he would publish a certain kind of
history of Utah. Since Bancroft is a millionaire, the Mormon offer was not
very tempting."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account