In the "Advancement of Learning" Bacon refers to the annotations of
books as being deficient. There was living at the end of the sixteenth
and beginning of the seventeenth century a scholar through whose hands
at least several thousand books passed. He appears to have made a
practice of annotating in the margins every book he read. The chief
purpose, however, of the notes, apparently, was to aid the memory, for
in some books nearly every name occurring in the text is carried into
the margin without comment. The notes are also accompanied by scrolls,
marks, and brackets, which support the contention that they are the work
of one man. The annotation of books was not a common practice then, nor
has it been since. If a reader takes up a hundred books in a second-hand
book shop he will probably not find more than one containing manuscript
notes, and not one in five hundred in which the annotations have been
systematically carried through. There does not appear to have been any
other scholar living at that time, with the exception of this one, who
was persistently making marginal notes on the books he read.
Spedding writes: "What became of his (Bacon's) books, which were left to
Sir John Constable and must have contained traces of his reading, we do
not know; but very few appear to have survived."
Mrs. Pott, in "Francis Bacon and his Secret Society," draws attention to
the mystery as to the disappearance of Bacon's library. "Which is a
mystery," she adds, "although the world has been content to take it
very apathetically. Where is Bacon's library? Undoubtedly the books
exist and are traceable. We should expect them to be recognisable by
marginal notes; yet those notes, whether in pencil or in ink, may have
been effaced. If annotated, Bacon and his friends would not wish his
books to attract public attention." And further on: "It is probable that
the latter (_i.e._, the books) will seldom or never be found to bear his
name or signature." And again: "Yet it may reasonably be anticipated
that some at least are 'noted in the margin,' or that some will be found
with traces of marks which were guides to the transcriber or amanuensis
as to the portions which were to be copied for future use in Bacon's
collections or book of commonplaces." Mrs. Pott's words were written in
a spirit of true prophecy.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account