The nature of the physical worldEddington, Arthur Stanley, Sir
Philosophy
The nature of the physical world
Eddington, Arthur Stanley, Sir
Physics -- Philosophy; Science -- Philosophy
In my observatory there is a telescope which condenses the light of
a star on a film of sodium in a photoelectric cell. I rely on the
classical theory to conduct the light through the lenses and focus
it in the cell; then I switch on to the quantum theory to make the
light fetch out electrons from the sodium film to be collected in an
electrometer. If I happen to transpose the two theories, the quantum
theory convinces me that the light will never get concentrated in the
cell and the classical theory shows that it is powerless to extract the
electrons if it does get in. I have no logical reason for not using the
theories this way round; only experience teaches me that I must not.
Sir William Bragg was not overstating the case when he said that we use
the classical theory on Mondays, Wednesday and Fridays, and the quantum
theory on Tuesdays, Thursdays and Saturdays. Perhaps that ought to make
us feel a little sympathetic towards the man whose philosophy of the
universe takes one form on weekdays and another form on Sundays.
In the last century—and I think also in this—there must have been
many scientific men who kept their science and religion in watertight
compartments. One set of beliefs held good in the laboratory and
another set of beliefs in church, and no serious effort was made
to harmonise them. The attitude is defensible. To discuss the
compatibility of the beliefs would lead the scientist into regions of
thought in which he was inexpert; and any answer he might reach would
be undeserving of strong confidence. Better admit that there was some
[Pg 195]
truth both in science and religion; and if they must fight, let it be
elsewhere than in the brain of a hard-working scientist. If we have
ever scorned this attitude, Nemesis has overtaken us. For ten years we
have had to divide modern science into two compartments; we have one
set of beliefs in the classical compartment and another set of beliefs
in the quantum compartment. Unfortunately our compartments are not
watertight.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account