His thoughts, whether conceived in a white heat of frenzy, or with
deliberate coolness and sly calculations for the main chance, were
probably not written down in any definite manner during his lifetime. It
is not even certain whether he could read or write. He delighted in the
appellation, "The Illiterate Prophet," possibly on account of his
humility and possibly because he knew that inspired ignorance had been
the indisputable prerogative of all successful prophets in the past.
Indeed, the very fact that he was unlearned was rightly supposed to
increase the miraculous nature of his revelations. As he tossed the
divine emanations from his lips, they were sometimes recorded by
hireling scribes upon palm leaves, leather, stones, the shoulder blades
or ribs of camels and goats. But often they were not immediately written
down at all; the Prophet would go around spouting forth his utterances
to his followers, who, trained from infancy to memorize verses and songs
of every sort with infallible precision, would piously commit them to
memory. Such is the Koran, and through its instrumentality, Allah the
Wise, The Only Wise, revealed his immutable decrees: to the good, the
rewards of a Paradise that utterly beggared the Christian Heaven; to the
bad, the punishments of a Hell that contained an infinity of such
refined tortures of heat, and even of cold as neither the most
imaginatively gifted Jew or Christian had yet conceived.
Reinach aptly states, "It is humiliating to the human intellect to think
that this mediocre literature has been the subject of innumerable
commentaries and that millions of men are still wasting time in
absorbing it." Over one hundred and sixty million are adherents of the
Koran.
In an objective analysis, excluding the emotional factors of religious
bias, Mohammed would as unquestionably be considered a victim of mental
disturbances as an individual living in our own day and manifesting the
same symptoms.
Mohammed was the subject of illusions, hallucinations, and delusions. He
had suicidal tendencies, and he had alternating periods of exhilaration
and depression. To simply assert that he was an epileptic does not
explain these symptoms. For epileptics cannot throw a fit at will.
However, we know that ten per cent of epileptics develop mental
diseases, no particular psychosis but a loss of mental and moral sense.
There are two types of individuals who can produce seizures such as
Mohammed was wont to evoke at will. One type is the hysterical, and the
other is that degraded individual who for the sake of collecting alms
will place a piece of soap in his mouth, enter a crowded street, fall
to the ground, and proceed to foam at the mouth and twist and contort
himself as an epileptic does. That is the charlatan, the faker, and that
brings us to the second aspect of his (Mohammed's) character.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account