The New Irish Constitution: An Exposition and Some Arguments
History
The New Irish Constitution: An Exposition and Some Arguments
Home rule -- Ireland; Ireland -- Politics and government
The first Department on my list is the Treasury. Here the new Irish
Administration must break entirely fresh ground and build from the
foundation. An Irish Exchequer must be created, a system of Treasury
Regulations and accounts must be evolved; an Irish Consolidated Fund must
be established; and a Bank must be selected with which the Irish
Government will bank. (Much pressure will, I anticipate, be brought to
bear on the Irish Ministry to distribute its favours in this connexion;
but, it would, I submit, be highly inconvenient to keep accounts with
separate banks). At present the Chief Secretary’s office in Dublin Castle
has a financial section, but the new Government will derive no inspiration
from its procedure. It will be better to look for precedents in Whitehall.
They will show a Treasury Board composed of members of the Government but
with the responsibility resting on one called the Chancellor of the
Exchequer who is answerable to Parliament for the country’s finances and,
subject to the decision of the Cabinet, possesses complete control over
them (excepting the Army and Navy Estimates). It will, I suggest, be wise
for the Irish Legislature to follow this precedent, and place the Irish
Treasury in charge of a Body of Commissioners (being Members of the
Parliament) with a Treasurer or Chancellor of the Exchequer, specially
responsible to it.
The governing principle, from the parliamentary point of view, of our
financial system, is that no expenditure can be proposed to Parliament
except by a Minister of the Crown.(74) I trust that the principle will be
reproduced in the Irish Parliament, and rigidly enforced. In no other way
can an adequate safeguard be provided against irresponsible and hasty
proposals for spending public money.
The Imperial Treasury at present, exercises financial control over every
department and branch of the public service (over the Army and Navy
estimates I believe the control is less effective than in other
directions). This is a wholesome practice, and it should be copied by the
Irish Legislature with one qualification. At present, the financial
control of the Treasury is occasionally accompanied by a degree of
administrative interference which I venture to think is sometimes
injurious to the public interests. The Treasury is deficient in
administrative knowledge; and for this reason its interference has not
infrequently led to inefficiency. Some administrative restraint is, of
course, inseparable from financial control; but when money is sanctioned
for a particular purpose, the administrative officers on the spot can
regulate detailed expenditure better than gentlemen at a distance.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account