The Norse discoverers of America : $b the Wineland sagas translated & discussedGathorne-Hardy, G. M. (Geoffrey Malcolm)
History
The Norse discoverers of America : $b the Wineland sagas translated & discussed
Gathorne-Hardy, G. M. (Geoffrey Malcolm)
America -- Discovery and exploration -- Norse
In a fifteenth-century manuscript incorporated in the collection of
scientific treatises known as _Rímbegla_ the following passage is to
be found (p. 482): ‘Between Bergen and Nidaros (Trondhjem) there are
about four degrees, so one degree comes to about a nautical “tylft”.’
Pausing here, we may observe that the voyage from Bergen to Trondhjem
was evidently recognized to be four nautical ‘tylfts’. The passage
continues: ‘now a degree on land and a “tylft” at sea are equal, and
there are two “tylfts” in a day’s (dægur) sailing.’ To the expression
used for a day’s sailing attention will have to be directed later on,
but for the present it may be allowed to stand in the non-controversial
form into which it is translated above. Taken as an accurate statement
of the case, this quotation from _Rímbegla_ has given us the following
table:
1 vika = 5 nautical miles.
1 tylft = 1 degree (60 nautical miles).
2 tylfts = 1 day’s sail (120 nautical miles).
Now if a day’s sail be taken here as equivalent to twenty-four hours,
we have precisely the divisions of distance which, as I said at the
outset, we ought to expect where the measurement is effected by time.
A ‘vika’ represents an hour’s run, a ‘tylft’ twelve hours, and a day’s
sail twenty-four hours. Whether, the geographical distances which they
are alleged to represent have been correctly stated is another matter,
into which we may now look a little more closely.
It is evident that the assumed correspondence between a ‘tylft’ and
a degree, which, having regard to the state of navigation in the
saga period, must in any case have been accidental, rests upon the
hypothesis that the length of a voyage from Bergen to Trondhjem is
four degrees or 240 nautical miles. The difference of latitude between
the two places is in fact little more than three degrees, and even
the rhumb-line connecting Bergen and Trondhjem is not 240 nautical
miles in length; this error, however, need not necessarily have any
effect on the author’s calculation. But on working out the shortest
distance covered by a ship sailing from the one place to the other,
it is apparent that in calling this distance four degrees a serious
under-statement is made which vitiates the conclusion arrived at.
This distance as sailed at the present day is said to be 318 nautical
miles, and calculation or inspection of a chart will show that it is
impossible to bring it much below 300, so that if this represents four
‘tylfts’, calculated by time, as it probably did, our table must be
revised as follows:
1 vika = 6·25 miles.
1 tylft = 75 miles.
1 day’s sail = 150 miles.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account