The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophetsMcCaul, Alexander
Religion
The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophets
McCaul, Alexander
Judaism -- Works to 1900
“The Sambation is a certain river of stones, which rolls along all the
days of the week, but on the Sabbath-day it is perfectly still.” He also
explains to us what is meant by the smoke not ascending from the grave
on the Sabbath-day, in the following note:
קברו של אביו דטורנוס רופוס כל ימות השבת היה מעלה עשן שהיה נדון ונשרף
ובשבת פושעי גיהנם שובתין ׃
“On all the other days of the year a smoke was made to ascend from the
grave of the father of Turnus Rufus, for he was suffering the judgment
of burning, but on the Sabbath-day, the sinners in hell have rest.”
Whether Turnus Rufus saw the smoke or not, the Talmud does not inform
us, but the Bereshith Rabba, another work of equal credibility in such
matters of fact, tells the story a little more at length, and informs us
that he was not satisfied with the argument drawn from the river
Sambation. R. Akiva therefore advised him to cite his father from the
dead on the Sabbath and the other days, and that this experiment would
convince him. To this Turnus Rufus consented, and the results are
described in the following words:—
וסלק כל יומי דשבתא ובשבתא לא סלק בחד בשבא אסקיה אמר ליה מן דמיתת
איתעבדית יהודי אתמהא מפני מה עלית כל ימות השבת ושבת לא עלית אמר ליה כל
מי שאינו משמר את השבת אצלכם ברצונו כאן הוא משמר אותו בעל כרחו . אמר לו
וכי עמל יש לכם שאתם עמלים כל ימות השבת ובשבת אתם נוחין אמר לו כל ימות
השבת אנו נידונין ובשבת אנו נוחין ׃
“His father came up every day of the week, but on the Sabbath-day he did
not come up. On the first day of the week he brought him up again, and
said to him, Father, hast thou been made a Jew since thy death; why is
it that thou comest up on all the other days of the week, but not on
Sabbath? He replied, Whosoever will not keep the Sabbath voluntarily in
your world, must keep it here in spite of himself. He then said, Father,
have you then got work on the other days of the week, and rest on the
Sabbath? The father replied, On the other days of the week we are
judged, but on the Sabbath we are at rest.” (Bereshith Rabba, fol. 9,
col. 4.) Such are the legends which the Jewish Prayer-book, on the
solemn feast of Pentecost, stamps with all the authority of authentic
history. Is it necessary to prove to the Jews of England that both these
stories are utterly untrue? Is it necessary to say, that there is not,
and never was, such a river as the Sambation? Within a century the world
has been explored in every direction. From Cooke to Kotzebue the globe
has been many times circumnavigated, but none has brought us any tidings
of the Sambation. Since the times of Benjamin of Tudela, and Abraham
Peritsol, there has been a host of adventurous travellers, but none had
the luck to behold the miraculous torrent of the Sambation. In this very
city Jews are occasionally found from every part of the world, but from
the banks of the Sambation no messenger has yet arrived. The whole
account is a fiction, and is unworthy of a place in the prayers of the
Jews of England.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account