The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophetsMcCaul, Alexander
Religion
The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophets
McCaul, Alexander
Judaism -- Works to 1900
become totally insensible on week-days as well as Sabbath-days; and thus
the enforcement of this one law would produce universal selfishness, and
this would certainly not promote the happiness of the world. But take
another case of a man, who leaves his home on the Friday morning to go a
short distance into the country, intending to return before the
commencement of the Sabbath; he meets with an accident, and breaks a
limb; on the Sabbath he is sufficiently restored to think of the anxiety
of his family, and writes a short note to inform them of his state, this
act of common love and kindness would cost him his life; nay, if he had
only begun the letter, and then overcome by fear or weakness, had left
it unfinished, a rabbinic tribunal would condemn him to be stoned.
כל המתכוון לעשות מלאכה בשבת והתחיל בה ועשה כשיעור חייב אע׳׳פ שלא השלים
כל המלאכה שנתכוון להשלימה , כיצד הרי שנתכוון לכתוב אגרת או שטר בשבת אין
אומרים לא יתחייב זה עד שישלים חפצו ויכתות כל השטר או כל האגרת אלא
משיכתוב שתי אותיות חייב ׃
“Whosoever intends to do any work on the Sabbath, and begins it, and
does a certain measure, is guilty, although he does not finish all that
he intended. How so? Suppose he intended to write a letter, or a
contract on the Sabbath, it is not to be thought that he will not be
guilty until he finish his business, and write the whole contract or the
whole letter. On the contrary, as soon as he shall have written two
letters (of the alphabet) he is guilty.” (Ibid.) And consequently, if it
can be proved, must be stoned. Every one’s daily experience will tell
them of the many similar cases where a letter may be necessary for the
peace or well-being of an individual or a family, and where the delay of
a day would be a serious injury. If rabbinism held the reins of power,
the anxiety, the sorrow, the injury must all be endured; the Sabbath-day
must be made a burden and a curse, instead of a blessing, or life itself
must be exposed to danger. But this would not be the only misery. These
sanguinary laws would, as religious laws, bind the consciences of the
weak and superstitious. A man’s domestics, or his children, or even his
wife, would become spies over all his Sabbath doings, and the denouncers
of every transgression; and thus domestic confidence, without which not
even the shadow of happiness can exist, would be destroyed, and a man’s
foes would be those of his own household. Much has lately been thought
and said about the sanguinary nature of the laws of England, but the
laws of Draco himself were merciful when compared with the religious
enactments of the rabbies. Draco only sentenced to death men convicted
of a crime. The oral law condemns to stoning the man, woman, or child
who will venture to write two letters of the alphabet, or even who will
extinguish fire to prevent a public injury. Nay, in some cases, where it
actually pronounces a man innocent, it nevertheless commands him to be
flogged.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account