The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophetsMcCaul, Alexander
Religion
The old paths, or the Talmud tested by Scripture: Being a comparison of the principles and doctrines of modern Judaism with the religion of Moses and the prophets
McCaul, Alexander
Judaism -- Works to 1900
מי שהחשיך לו בדרך בערב שבת ועמו כיס אם יש עמו נברי וחמור יתן כיסו לנכרי
אף לאחר שתחשך ולא יניחנו על החמור , אבל אם מצא מציאה אינו יכול ליתנה
לנכרי אלא אם כן באה לידו מבעוד יום דהשתא הויא ככיסו , אין עמו נכרי
יניחנה על החמור כשהוא הולך ויזהר ליטול ממנו בכל שעה שיעמוד , וכשיחזור
וילך יניחנו עליו , היה עמו חמור וחרש שוטה וקטן יניחנו על החמור ולא יתננה
לאחד מאלה כיון שהם אדם כמותו , היה עמו חרש ושוטה יתננו לשוטה לפי שאין לו
דעת כלל , שוטה וקטן יתננו לשוטה שהקטן יבוא לכלל דעת , חרש וקטן יתננה למי
שירצה , אין עמו לא זה ולא זה יטלטלנו פחרת פחות מארבע אמות ׃
“If a man travelling on the Sabbath-eve be overtaken by night,[28] and
has with him a purse, and there be also with him a Gentile and an ass,
let him give his purse to the Gentile, even after it be dark, but let
him not lay it on the ass.[29] But if he find anything, he may not give
it to the Gentile, unless it came into his hand whilst it was yet day,
for then it is a similar case to that of his purse. If there be no
Gentile with him, then let him lay it on the ass, whilst he is moving,
but let him take great care to take it off every time he stands still.
But when he begins to move again, then let him lay it on. If there be
with him an ass, and a deaf and dumb person, an idiot and a child, then
let him lay it on the ass, but let him not give it to one of these, for
they are human beings like himself. If there be with him a deaf and dumb
person and an idiot, let him give it to the idiot, as he has no
understanding at all. If an idiot and a child, let him give it to the
idiot, for the child will be reckoned amongst those that have
understanding. If a deaf and dumb person and a child, let him give it to
whichever he pleases. If there be with him neither one nor the other,
let him move it along gradually, each time less than four ells.” (Orach
Chaim, sec. 266.) Here again the great concern is to observe the form
and letter of the rabbinical command, which represents the carrying of a
purse on the Sabbath-day as work, and therefore unlawful. The law of
Moses says nothing either one way or the other, but leaves it to every
man’s conscience. The rabbies who made it unlawful soon found that
serious inconvenience might arise, as in the case of a man on a journey
overtaken by the Sabbath, before he could get to a resting-place. What
is he to do, is he to leave his purse behind rather than profane the
Sabbath? That alternative the Pharisees did not like, and therefore set
their wits to work to devise some plan, whereby the outward form might
be observed, and yet the purse be safely conveyed along with its
proprietor. In the first place, they allow it to be given to a Gentile,
but every man of common sense will see that this only saves the outward
appearance, for it be unlawful to carry the purse, it must be equally
unlawful to cause it to be carried, for he who commands or causes work
to be done is really and in the sight of God the doer, just as he who
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account