The organisation of thought, educational and scientificWhitehead, Alfred North
Philosophy
The organisation of thought, educational and scientific
Whitehead, Alfred North
Education
This seems to me to be a profound mistake. It implies that a merely
mechanical knowledge without understanding of ways of arriving at
mathematical results is useful in applied science. It is of no use
whatever. The results themselves can all be found stated in the
appropriate pocket books and in other elementary works of reference. No
one when applying a result need bother himself as to why it is true. He
accepts it and applies it. What is of supreme importance in physics and
in engineering is a mathematically trained mind, and such a mind can
only be acquired by a proper mathematical discipline.
I fully admit that the proper way to start such a subject as the
differential calculus is to plunge quickly into the use of the notation
in a few absurdly simple cases, with a crude explanation of the idea
of rates of increase. The notation as thus known can then be used by
the lecturers in the Physical and Engineering Laboratories. But the
mathematical training of the applied scientists consists in making
these ideas precise and the proofs accurate.
I hope that the thesis of this paper respecting the position of logical
precision in the teaching of mathematics has been rendered plain. The
habit of logical precision with its necessary concentration of thought
upon abstract ideas is not wholly possible in the initial stages of
learning. It is the ideal at which the teacher should aim. Also logical
precision, in the sense of logical explicitness, is not an absolute
thing: it is an affair of more or less. Accordingly the quantity of
explicitness to be introduced at each stage of progress must depend
upon the practical judgment of the teacher. Lastly, in a sense, the
instructed mind is less explicit; for it travels more quickly over a
well-remembered path, and may save the trouble of putting into words
trains of thought which are very obvious to it. But on the other
hand it atones for this rapidity by a concentration on every subtle
point where a fallacy can lurk. The habit of logical precision is the
instinct for the subtle difficulty.
CHAPTER VI
THE ORGANISATION OF THOUGHT
(_Presidential Address to Section A, British Association, Newcastle,
1916_)
THE subject of this address is the organisation of thought, a topic
evidently capable of many diverse modes of treatment. I intend more
particularly to give some account of that department of logical science
with which some of my own studies have been connected. But I am
anxious, if I can succeed in so doing, to handle this account so as to
exhibit the relation with certain considerations which underlie general
scientific activities.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account