The Origin and Development of Christian Dogma: An essay in the science of historyTuthill, Charles A. H.
Religion
The Origin and Development of Christian Dogma: An essay in the science of history
Tuthill, Charles A. H.
Christianity -- Origin
After the overthrow of the northern kingdom, this national Messianic
ideal naturally included the restoration of its scattered captives to
their native land. The Samaritan captivity seemed to the prophets to
be designed by Jahveh as a destruction of the fatal system of dualism
which had undermined Israel’s strength. Henceforth the Israelites were
to be one people, with Jerusalem as their centre and capital. When
the kingdom of Judah, too, was conquered, and its chief classes also
carried away into captivity, of course the restoration of exiles
became the most important part of the Messiah’s mission. But even
before this, the prophets of Judah, warned by the fate of Samaria, and
aware of the customs of the Assyrian and Chaldean empires, foresaw
and predicted the great captivity, and, in consequence, included a
subsequent restoration in their Messianic dreams. Thus by nearly all
the prophets the restoration of the captives to their country was
regarded as the prelude to the events of the Messianic period, either
to be accomplished by the Messiah personally, or to be immediately
followed by his appearance. In so confidently predicting the
restoration, the prophets were only giving expression to the national
hopefulness, but they might have based their expectation on stronger
grounds. The cohesive influence of their religion was sure to prevent
the Jewish exiles from being lost in the peoples among whom they were
placed; and if they managed to preserve their nationality, it was
likely that, sooner or later, they would be restored to Judæa. The
absence of this influence was probably the reason why no restoration
followed the captivity of the kingdom of Samaria. The religion of
Jahveh was never so strong in it as in the kingdom of Judah, and must
have been then too weak to serve as a national support. When the
second captivity occurred, Judaism was able to meet it and to save the
nationality it was designed to destroy.
After the restoration had taken place, fulfilling the predictions of
the prophets under circumstances very different from those which they
had expected, the Messianic ideal had, of course, to be disconnected
from it. Sufficient ground still existed for looking forward to the
coming of the Messiah. Israel was only semi-independent, a small
state at the mercy of Gentile masters. But the disappointment of the
Messianic expectations which had been connected with the restoration
must have given a blow to the spirit of prediction. During the
rebuilding of Jerusalem, the voices of the prophets grew faint and
feeble; and after the restoration was complete, only one broke the
silence. The Jews had to fall back on faith in the ultimate fulfilment
of earlier prophecies, regarding the establishment of Judaism as the
religion of all Israel, as the beginning of the reconciliation of
Jahveh and his people which should finally secure their prosperity.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account