The origin and development of the moral ideasWestermarck, Edward
Philosophy
The origin and development of the moral ideas
Westermarck, Edward
Ethics; Ethics -- History; Prehistoric peoples
Very generally drunkenness is recognised as a ground of extenuation.
We hear from various sources that the North American Indians were
exceedingly merciful to intoxicated offenders. According to
Charlevoix, the Iroquois "suffer themselves to be ill used by drunken
people, without defending themselves, for fear of hurting them. If you
endeavour to shew them the folly of this conduct, they say, 'Why
should we hurt them? They know not what they do.'" Even "if a savage
kills another belonging to his cabin, if he is drunk (and they often
counterfeit drunkenness when they intend to commit such actions),[183]
all the consequence is, that they pity and weep for the dead. 'It is a
misfortune (they say), the murderer knew not what he did.'"[184] James
makes a similar statement with reference to the Omahas.[185] In his
description of the aborigines of Pennsylvania, Blome observes, "It is
rare that they fall out, if sober; and if drunk they forgive it,
saying, it was the drink, and not the man that abused them."[186]
Benjamin Franklin tells us of some Indians who had misbehaved in a
state of intoxication, and in consequence sent three of their old men
to apologise; "the orator acknowledged the fault, but laid it upon the
rum, and then endeavoured to excuse the rum."[187] The detestable
deeds which men did under the influence of _pulcre_, or the native
Mexican wine, the Aztecs attributed to the god of wine or to the wine
itself, and not in the least to the drunken man. Indeed, if anybody
spoke ill of or insulted an intoxicated person, he was liable to be
punished for disrespect to the god by which that person was supposed
to be possessed. {279} Hence, says Sahagun, it was believed, not
without ground, that the Indians made themselves drunk on purpose to
commit with impunity crimes for which they would have been punished if
they had committed them sober.[188]
[Footnote 183: _Cf._ Hennepin, _op. cit._ p. 71.]
[Footnote 184: Charlevoix, _op. cit._ ii. 23, 25. According to Loskiel
(_History of the Mission of the United Brethren among the Indians in
North America_, i. 16), the Iroquois, though they laid all the blame
on the rum, punished severely murder committed in drunkenness.]
[Footnote 185: James, _Expedition from Pittsburgh to the Rocky
Mountains_, i. 265.]
[Footnote 186: Blome, in Buchanan, _North American Indians_, p. 328.]
[Footnote 187: Franklin, _Autobiography_, ch. ix. (_Works_, i. 164).]
[Footnote 188: Sahagun, _Historia general de las cosas de Nueva
España_, i. 22, vol. i. 40.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account