The fact is, the villagers are plain, common-sense men and women, and
what they want for their children is that they be better fitted for the
struggle of life. They do not observe that to be the case at present.
They judge by results, and the results are not good, they say.
In fact, except as to the actual acquisition of reading, writing, and
arithmetic, which may or may not be of much use, the teaching--and
still more than the teaching, the influence--is bad. It unfits for
life, it gives wrong ideals, or it kills all ideals.
The higher education is, I think, worse. It follows an imported
system, and in the importation all the good is left out. In England a
boy's real education comes from association with the other boys and
from his father. From them he learns whatever he does learn of
conduct, of ambition to true ends, of acting in concert, of ability to
judge for himself and stick up for himself.
In India a wrong ideal has been conceived from the beginning. It has
been assumed, tacitly maybe, that an Englishman is the final and
completely perfected work of God and man, and that all nations should
copy him and try to become, if not a sterling Englishman, at least an
electro-plate one.
That is disastrous. It depresses the people by depreciating their own
races and holding up an objective which is impossible, and if possible
would be wrong.
There are in the pasts of nearly all Oriental people ideals which are
quite as good as ours, and far better fitted for them. Are these ever
taught to them? India once led the civilisation of the world; is that
past ever brought up and explained and realised for them? Never, I
think.
Further, higher education to be of any use must be objective. You must
know what you want the boy to be. What does Government want the
products of its higher education to be? I have no idea. Has the
Government?
Of what use are these products of the higher education in India? They
are useful but for two things, to be lawyers or pleaders, or to be
clerks. They are dealers in words, and not in facts or in humanity.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account