The Passing of the Idle RichMartin, Frederick Townsend
History
The Passing of the Idle Rich
Martin, Frederick Townsend
Rich people -- United States; United States -- Social conditions -- 1865-1918; Wealth -- United States
I hesitate to undertake any extensive review of the great charities
and reforms that have sprung out of this new impulse that has moved
the rich to study the poor. I hesitate not because there is dearth of
material, but because of my own knowledge. I know that the facts of
record are but a very small part of all the facts in the case. The
tremendous benefactions of a Rockefeller, a Carnegie, a Mrs. Sage, do
not begin to measure the organized and unorganized charities that have
been inaugurated by the wealthy within the past ten years.
Personally, I do not think very much about the forms of charity that
are to-day most prevalent amongst the wealthy. Millions of dollars
every year are poured indiscriminately into all sorts of hoppers here
in New York, in the vain hope that they will help to bring about
better conditions. Money-charity, if I may call it so, seems to me a
beautiful thing if it is really done in a spirit of helpfulness--but,
alas, how vain it is! I do not know but that, in the case of more
than half the recipients of charity of this indiscriminate sort, it
does more harm than good. This I do know, that, according to the best
estimates obtainable, from eighteen per cent. to twenty-five per cent.
of the people of New York State accept charity every year. This is
a matter of record. How many more are the recipients of unrecorded
charity I do not know, but I should not be surprised if forty per
cent. of the population of the greatest state of the Union are the
beneficiaries of charity, of one sort and another, in such a year as
1908, for instance.
Professor Bushnell, in an estimate made some years ago, estimated
that nearly two hundred million dollars a year was spent upon the
maintenance of abnormal dependents in the United States. Think, then,
of the amount of money that must be lavished upon the thousand and one
indiscriminate charities extended to people who cannot be classed as
dependents at all.
Charity, beautiful as it is in many instances, is a hopeless answer to
the questions of the day. The wonderful growth of it in the past three
or four years in the social world to which I belong is hopeful, not
because of the actual good it has accomplished or can accomplish, but
simply because it is another index of the times, another indubitable
sign that the wealthy men and women of Society are really throwing
their hearts and minds into the mighty problem of adjusting the
relationship between the classes which are so rapidly drifting apart.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account