Entelechy is therefore not energy, nor any particular form of
energy-transformation, and in its operations energy is neither used
nor dissipated. In all that it does the law of conservation holds with
all the rigidity with which we imagine it to hold in purely inorganic
happening--at least we need not assume that it does not hold--and this
is the essential difference between the entelechian manifestations and
the manifestations of the “vital” or “biotic” forces or energies of the
historic systems of vitalism. It is essentially arrangement, or order
of happening, and it is therefore a non-energetic agency. The workman
who may build half-a-dozen zigzag walls, or an archway, or a small
house, from the same materials and with the expenditure of the same
quantity of energy, is indeed an energetical agent, but he is more than
that. He is a physico-chemical system in which any one phase is not
determined by the preceding phase. Different results may arise from the
same initial arrangement of materials and energies, and this is because
the system contains more than the material and energetical elements.
It contains the intelligence or entelechy of the workman.
What is this entelechy? Sooner of later in all our speculation on
organic happening we must cross the arbitrary line which divides the
space of our concepts from the non-spatial--the intensive from the
extensive. Just as the physicists have left materiality behind them
in their speculations and treatment of the phenomena of radiation, so
biology must attempt to trace back the materiality of the organism to
something which is immaterial. Just as physics has now abandoned the
idea of matter as something which consists of discrete particles, or
atoms, having extension in space, and which therefore exclude each
other, so biology must seek the origin of living things, not in the
hypothetical “biophoridæ,” or other ultimate living material particles,
but in the intensive manifoldness of entelechy. There is a manifoldness
in the potentiality which the simple and homogeneous ovum possesses
of becoming the heterogeneous adult organism. This manifoldness, says
the mechanistic biologist, consists of a manifoldness of extended
material units, the determinants of Weismann, and the organisation
that arranges these units--what is this organisation? It cannot be
a three-dimensional machinery, as all close analysis of the facts
of development and regulation shows. It is then something that is
intensive, something which is not in space, but which _acts into
space_, and the result of which is manifested in spatial material
arrangements and activities. Vague and incomprehensible as is this
concept of the activities of the organisms, it is only vague and
incomprehensible because we have been accustomed to express all
chemical and physical happening in terms of the fundamental concepts
of matter and energy, and the science of the last two centuries
has left us with a terminology which applies strictly to operations
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account