"Why should the factory produce more washing machines? Who would want
one? The housewife would simply reposit the dirt from her clothes
into her flowerbed, without using water and soap. Or, more likely,
reposit new clothes with different colors, fabrics, and styles. The
Matter Repositor would eliminate textile mills and clothing factories.
Earth's oceans have vast enough quantities of seaweed to eliminate the
growing of cotton, wool, or flax. Or, again, you could reposit the
chemical elements, either from the soil or from seawater."
Jerry pondered the extensive implications of these revelations.
Finally he said, "What it boils down to is this. All Earth's bustling
material activity, all the logging and construction, the mining and
manufacturing, the planting and fishing, the printing and postal
service, the great transportation and shipping effort, the cleaning and
painting, the sewage disposal, even the bathing and self-adornment,
consist, when you analyze them, of one process only--_putting something
from where you don't want it to where you do_. There's not one single,
solitary Earth invention or service left to advertise!"
"Nothing," the Ambassador agreed. "Which is exactly why advertising has
not developed on the Federated Planets. You're fortunate that Earth
doesn't have Matter Repositors. You'd be out of a job if it did."
"Oh, no!" Jerry said. "I could still advertise the gadget to end all
gadgets--the Matter Repositor itself. I know other people have asked
you this before, but could an Earth company get a franchise to import
those machines here, or the license rights to manufacture them?"
"No," the Ambassador said, briefly and definitely.
"Mr. Ambassador," Jerry protested, "you've gone to a lot of trouble to
explain things you must already be tired of explaining to Earthmen,
just so I personally could be sure they weren't merely rumors or
misinterpretations. Now that I get down to the real point, you suddenly
become blunt and unqualified. Why?"
"Because there's a very serious question of ethics involved, wherever a
more advanced civilization comes in contact with a relatively primitive
one. For instance, when the white men came to America, the aborigines
were introduced to gunpowder and firewater."
"So you people are keeping Matter Repositors away from us, like a mama
keeping candy away from a baby who's hollering for it, because it's not
good for him! You'd pass up a chance to name your own price--"
"The very way you phrase that remark indicates the danger. You regard
personal gain as the strongest of motives, which means that Matter
Repositors would be used for that, even by such unusually intelligent
members of your race as yourself."
"Don't softsoap me," Jerry said angrily. "Not after you just got
through saying that we Earthlings are nothing but naked savages,
compared to the high and mighty super-beings on other planets!"
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account