"I apologize for my phraseology," the Ambassador said. "With my limited
command of your language--"
"Your limited command, nuts! I suppose you supermen enjoy seeing us
naked savages squirm. Why talk sanctimoniously about the damage you
might do, when you know damn well the damage has already been done?
Just the news that something as advanced as the Matter Repositor exists
has sent unemployment to a new high, and the stock market to a new low.
And you theorize about ethics, while denying us the only cure!" Jerry
found himself fighting a nearly irresistible impulse to smash his fist
into that too-perfect profile--which, he realized glumly, would only
prove the Ambassador's point about savages.
"Here, here," the Ambassador said benevolently, "let's have another
drink. Then we'll see whether I can make it clear to you why the actual
importation of Matter Repositors would cause much more trouble on Earth
than the announcement of their existence, bad as the effect of that has
been. To begin with, I admit I made a very serious error in mentioning
the device at all before the U.N. Assembly. I intended merely to
explain how I came here without a spaceship. After that, I was flooded
with questions; I could no more avoid answering them than I could
courteously avoid answering the questions you've been asking today."
"You mean you super-beings actually admit you're human enough to make
mistakes?" Jerry asked, somewhat mollified.
"Of course we make mistakes. We try not to make the same one twice.
You see, we once made the mistake of importing Matter Repositors to a
planet whose natural resources and social concepts weren't adequate
for the device. That was a long time ago, and they haven't recovered
from the effects yet. Suppose a consignment of ten thousand Matter
Repositors arrived on Earth tomorrow. Under your economic system, who
would get them?"
"The ten thousand people or corporations who had the most money to pay
for them, I guess. Unless government agencies grabbed 'em."
"Can you guarantee that of the ten thousand people on Earth who have
the most money, not one is unscrupulous?"
"Gosh, no!" Jerry said. "I don't think there's any doubt that to stay
in business very long, a man or a company has to have a certain amount
of business ethics. Nobody can gyp the public indefinitely. But a bank
robber might have a lot of cash, or a confidence man, or a cluck with a
big inheritance."
"So, to be generous, let's assume that 9,999 of your wealthiest persons
are so ethical that they would never make any profit at the expense of
the general welfare. That leaves us one crook. What would he reposit
first?"
"Hmm.... Maybe the gold at Fort Knox."
"And what effect would that have on Earth's business?"
"I'm not quite sure," Jerry admitted. "I'm no shark on monetary theory,
just the kind of large-scale salesman who makes mass production
possible. But it certainly wouldn't do the world situation any good."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account