The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other Essays — John Shaqi
The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other EssaysVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other Essays
Veblen, Thorstein
Economics; Science
In these speculative ranges of knowledge it is possible to form and to
maintain habits of thought which shall be consistent with themselves and
with the habit of mind and run of tradition prevalent in the community
at the time, though not thereby consistent with the material actualities
of life in the community. Yet this range of speculative generalisation,
which makes up the higher learning of the barbarian culture, is also
controlled, checked, and guided by the community's habits of life; it,
too, is an integral part of the scheme of life and is an outcome of the
habituation enforced by experience. But it does not rest immediately on
men's dealings with the refractory phenomena of brute creation, nor is
it guided, undisguised and directly, by the habitual material
(industrial) occupations. The fabric of institutions intervenes between
the material exigencies of life and the speculative scheme of things.
The higher theoretical knowledge, that body of tenets which rises to the
dignity of a philosophical or scientific system, in the early culture,
is a complex of habits of thought which reflect the habits of life
embodied in the institutional structure of society; while the lower,
matter-of-fact generalisations of work-day efficiency--the trivial
matters of course--reflect the workmanlike habits of life enforced by
the commonplace material exigencies under which men live. The
distinction is analogous, and indeed, closely related, to the
distinction between "intangible" and "tangible" assets. And the
institutions are more flexible, they involve or admit a larger margin of
error, or of tolerance, than the material exigencies. The latter are
systematised into what economists have called "the state of the
industrial arts," which enforce a somewhat rigorous standardisation of
whatever knowledge falls within their scope; whereas the institutional
scheme is a matter of law and custom, politics and religion, taste and
morals, on all of which matters men have opinions and convictions, and
on which all men "have a right to their own opinions." The scheme of
institutions is also not necessarily uniform throughout the several
classes of society; and the same institution (as, _e.g._, slavery,
ownership, or royalty) does not impinge with the same effect on all
parties touched by it. The discipline of any institution of servitude,
_e.g._, is not the same for the master as for the serf, etc. If there is
a considerable institutional discrepancy between an upper and a lower
class in the community, leading to divergent lines of habitual interest
or discipline; if by force of the cultural scheme the institutions of
society are chiefly in the keeping of one class, whose attention is then
largely engrossed with the maintenance of the scheme of law and order;
while the workmanlike activities are chiefly in the hands of another
class, in whose apprehension the maintenance of law and order is at the
best a wearisome tribulation, there is likely to be a similarly
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account