The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other Essays — John Shaqi
The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other EssaysVeblen, Thorstein
Philosophy
The Place of Science in Modern Civilisation, and Other Essays
Veblen, Thorstein
Economics; Science
considerable divergence or discrepancy between the speculative
knowledge, cultivated primarily by the upper class, and the work-day
knowledge which is primarily in the keeping of the lower class. Such, in
particular, will be the case if the community is organised on a coercive
plan, with well-marked ruling and subject classes. The important and
interesting institutions in such a case, those institutions which fill a
large angle in men's vision and carry a great force of authenticity, are
the institutions of coercive control, differential authority and
subjection, personal dignity and consequence; and the speculative
generalisations, the institutions of the realm of knowledge, are created
in the image of these social institutions of status and personal force,
and fall into a scheme drawn after the plan of the code of honor. The
work-day generalisations, which emerge from the state of the industrial
arts, concomitantly fall into a deeper obscurity, answering to the depth
of indignity to which workmanlike efficiency sinks under such a cultural
scheme; and they can touch and check the current speculative knowledge
only remotely and incidentally. Under such a bifurcate scheme of
culture, with its concomitant two-cleft systematisation of knowledge,
"reality" is likely to be widely dissociated from fact--that is to say,
the realities and verities which are accepted as authentic and
convincing on the plane of speculative generalisation; while science has
no show--that is to say, science in that modern sense of the term which
implies a close contact, if not a coincidence, of reality with fact.
Whereas, if the institutional fabric, the community's scheme of life,
changes in such a manner as to throw the work-day experience into the
foreground of attention and to center the habitual interest of the
people on the immediate material relations of men to the brute
actualities, then the interval between the speculative realm of
knowledge, on the one hand, and the work-day generalisations of fact, on
the other hand, is likely to lessen, and the two ranges of knowledge are
likely to converge more or less effectually upon a common ground. When
the growth of culture falls into such lines, these two methods and norms
of theoretical formulation may presently come to further and fortify one
another, and something in the way of science has at least a chance to
arise.
* * * * *
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account