Although I have presented here only a few of the leading features which
an analysis of the imitative processes reveals, enough has been said
to show how complicated and difficult the problem is, and to render
advisable a general summing up in more compact form of the results of
these somewhat rambling observations. It will not do to call imitation
instinct and leave it at that, since it is not a specific but quite
an involved reaction. Moreover, the condition of imitation, namely,
the tendency of movement ideas to produce corresponding movements,
is not itself instinctive; but we have seen that this tendency alone
does not explain all that we include under the name of imitation. This
tendency of the movement ideas must have special grounds furnished by
organic needs, and especially those which are instinctive; when the
general idea of movement is coincident with one of these the impulse
toward discharge becomes very strong. We cited in illustration of this
the general movement-impulse, nursing, curiosity (how is it done?),
belligerence (not only as regards distinctly hostile movements, but
sensation as well), recognition, and illusion. If there is nothing
else, then imitation taken alone is no instinct; it is only in very
close connection to instinct, as our biological point of view has
shown. It is, however, probable that these limits are not reached by
the simplest imitation, such as coughing, gaping, etc., and use may
be made of the hypothesis of transference (_loi de transfert_) from
specific social instincts, which are themselves the result of a certain
degree of imitativeness of the movement idea (agreement, answering, and
the like) to movement itself in cases involving the movements belonging
to a species. By this means natural selection of whatever developmental
factor is employed acquires an essential impetus. Whoever regards such
collaboration as probable will consider imitation as a phenomenon at
least similar to instinct.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account