Fiction -- History and criticism; Political fiction -- History and criticism; Politics in literature
In _The Charterhouse of Parma_ the witty and urbane Stendhal says,
“Politics in a work of literature are like a pistol-shot in the middle
of a concert, something loud and vulgar yet a thing to which it is
not possible to refuse one’s attention.” His own work contradicts
the great French novelist, yet his comment is perfectly accurate for
many other novelists. Politics in some modern novels of political
corruption, such as Charles F. Coe’s _Ashes_, do seem loud and vulgar,
and in books like Upton Sinclair’s the reader may hear not one pistol
shot but a cannonade. But this is not to say that the use of political
material must disrupt a work of literature. The trick, of course, is
all in knowing how. Harriet Beecher Stowe wrote an artistically weak,
politically successful work in _Uncle Tom’s Cabin_, while Fyodor
Dostoyevsky produced a politically unsuccessful, artistically enduring
classic in _The Possessed_.
The quality of these novels varies widely, just as would that of a
group dealing with religion, sex, or any other complex, controversial
theme. In general, the European novels considered here attain a
higher level than the American books. This is partly because only the
better European novels are treated. But they are also superior to
the best American works, except for a few comparatively recent ones,
because of the wider variety of political experience presented, the
greater concern with ideology and theory, and the deeper insight
into individual motivation and behavior. This in turn is probably due
to several factors. From the time when the United States attained
its independence until the end of the first quarter of this century,
it possessed a relatively stable set of doctrines and frames of
reference (compared to those existing in Europe) within which the
individual led his political life. Although American parties rose and
declined, although the Union was preserved, its borders expanded, and
international responsibility accepted, this evolution was orderly and
limited compared to that which occurred in Europe. The Declaration
of Independence, the Constitution, and the Bill of Rights provided a
stable yet sufficiently flexible political framework. Europe during the
same period reverberated with the French Revolution, the Napoleonic
Wars, the unification of Germany and Italy, and the Russian Revolution.
These were violent changes not only in theory but in the actual form
of government. It is not unnatural then that American political novels
range over a relatively narrower area, with their main emphasis on
local or national subjects, while those of European authors delineate
changing, conflicting, and radically different ideologies and resultant
events. It is only since the 1930s, with the increase in centralized
government, the impact of international Communism, and the recent
appearance on both the Right and the Left of what seem to be threats
to traditional American freedoms, that the American political novel
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account