Fiction -- History and criticism; Political fiction -- History and criticism; Politics in literature
In his helpful introduction to the Modern Library edition of _Fathers
and Sons_, Herbert Muller writes that Ivan Turgenev’s _A Sportsman’s
Sketches_, which appeared in 1852, had created an effect similar to
_Uncle Tom’s Cabin_ in America. _Fathers and Sons_ (1862), treating
revolutionaries like most of Turgenev’s books, had an even more lasting
effect. Although both the uproar and the Nihilist movement died
down, Muller declares that the novel “helped to form the mentality
of the later revolutionaries who established the Soviet Union.” The
story deals with the return from college of Arkady Kirsanov and his
friend Yevgeny Bazarov. Nihilist Bazarov dominates his disciple
Arkady. Conflict quickly erupts. Arkady’s father Nikolai is hurt by
the distance between them, and his uncle Pavel seizes upon a pretext
for a duel in which Bazarov wounds him. Bazarov’s father Vassily,
pathetically eager to be close to his son, finds the gulf between
them even greater than that separating Arkady and Nikolai. The two
generations--one giving allegiance to religion and the old regime,
the other to science and revolutionary Nihilism--have lost almost all
rapport with each other. Turgenev treats the perennial aspect of this
theme, yet he particularizes it to mid-nineteenth century Russia.
Eventually the gap between the Kirsanovs is narrowed as Arkady marries
and returns to administer the estate with his father. But before
Bazarov leaves he lashes out at Arkady:
You’re not made for our bitter, rough, lonely existence.... Our
dust would get into your eyes ... you’re admiring yourselves
unconsciously, you like to abuse yourselves; but we’re sick of
that--we want something else! we want to smash people!
It may be, as Muller says, that Turgenev’s mind was with the sons and
his heart with the fathers, that he tried to be fair. Here is a case
in which, regardless of intent, a novelist helped to shape a movement
which disrupted a world.
Tolstoy and Dostoyevsky reacted violently to Turgenev’s work. The
former challenged him to a duel and the latter attacked and caricatured
him mercilessly as Karamazinov in _The Possessed_ (1872), a violent
attack upon Nihilism. In his introduction to the Modern Library
edition, Avrahm Yarmolinsky declares that
Dostoyevsky’s avowed intention in writing it was to drive home
certain convictions of his, regardless of whether or not he met
the requirements of the art of fiction. He wanted to deal a body
blow to the rebels who threatened what he considered to be the
foundations of Russian life. Originally he conceived his novel as a
political lampoon, a pamphlet against the revolution.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account