Fiction -- History and criticism; Political fiction -- History and criticism; Politics in literature
Chapter One discusses some problems arising from a study of the
political novel. This is an important chapter and contains some homely
wisdom on the different approaches respectively of the novelist and
the political scientist. It should be stressed that certain crucial
points with respect to the analysis of human behavior in general can be
raised by comparing the techniques of the two kinds of observers and
reporters. The well-known remark about pictures being worth thousands
of words has occasionally been transposed to the effect that one good
story is worth a whole (and dry) textbook. This, of course, is an
attractive argument. But it does raise the fundamental question of what
analytical operations are performed by the novelist on the one hand and
the political scientist on the other. Offhand it would seem as though
there were important differences carrying beyond those of purposes
discussed by the author. Generally speaking, the novelist is primarily
concerned with a coherent story, with a whole fabric of description,
and with specific details while the political scientist is concerned
with events, processes, and factors, with abstractions from wholes and
with classes of general phenomena. The latter builds upon numerous
instances, upon gross data, and upon repeated patterns of behavior. The
former builds upon an amassing of individualized data fashioned into a
unique chronicle. The one gains richness and sacrifices capacity to
generalize, the other sacrifices detail for broad generalization. For
the novelist, Uncle Tom becomes a microcosm, a device for revealing
the tragedy of the whole Negro race in America through a portrait of
a single character. For the political scientist, Uncle Tom is lost in
what can be said of the entire group of which he is a member. Both are
limited and both pay a price accordingly. Clearly more is involved in
the different analytic techniques but it suffices to indicate one type
of issue raised in this study of the political novel.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account