The Principles of Psychology, Volume 2 (of 2)James, William
Science
The Principles of Psychology, Volume 2 (of 2)
James, William
Psychology
"Sensations... are psychical states _whose place_--so far as they
can be said to have one--_is the mind_. The transference of these
sensations from mere mental states to physical processes located
in the periphery of the body, or to qualities of things projected
in space external to the body, is a mental act. It may rather be
said to be a mental _achievement_ [cf. Cudworth, footnote 10,
as to knowledge being _conquering_], for it is an act which in
its perfection results from a long and intricate process of
development.... Two noteworthy stages, or 'epoch-making' achievements
in the process of elaborating the presentations of sense, require a
special consideration. These are '_localization_,' or the transference
of the composite sensations from mere states of the mind to processes
or conditions recognized as taking place at more or less definitely
fixed points or areas of the body; and '_eccentric projection_'
(sometimes called 'eccentric perception') or the giving to these
sensations an objective existence (in the fullest sense of the word
'objective') as qualities of objects situated within a field of space
and in contact with, or more or less remotely distant from, the
body."[37]
It seems to me that there is not a vestige of evidence for this view.
It hangs together with the opinion that our sensations are originally
devoid of all spatial content,[38] an opinion which I confess that I
am wholly at a loss to understand. As I look at my bookshelf opposite
I cannot frame to myself an idea, however imaginary, of any feeling
which I could ever possibly have got from it except the feeling of the
same big extended sort of outward fact which I now perceive. So far is
it from being true that our first way of feeling things is the feeling
of them as subjective or mental, that the exact opposite seems rather
to be the truth. Our earliest, most instinctive, least developed kind
of consciousness is the objective kind; and only as reflection becomes
developed do we become aware of an inner world at all. Then indeed
we enrich it more and more, even to the point of becoming idealists,
with the spoils of the outer world which at first was the only world
we knew. But subjective consciousness, aware of itself as subjective,
does not at first exist. Even an attack of pain is surely felt at first
objectively as something in space which prompts to motor reaction, and
to the very end it is located, not in the mind, but in some bodily part.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account