The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 1 of 2Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Science
The Propaganda for Reform in Proprietary Medicines, Vol. 1 of 2
Council on Pharmacy and Chemistry (American Medical Association)
Patent medicines
“=Something had to be done; and Burnham’s Soluble Iodin is that
which has been done=”
fulfils, in its blatant assertiveness, all the requirements of nostrum
advertising. The results of the analyses are not, therefore, a surprise.
Secrecy is just as essential today to the successful exploitation of
this class of proprietaries as it was before the demand for formulas
became so universal. The requirement of publicity is evaded, therefore,
in one of two ways: Either a formula is given which is false, or
at least meaningless, or else the claim is made that the method of
preparing the product is a unique and remarkable secret that is
possessed only by the manufacturers. The Burnham Soluble Iodin Company
uses the latter device.
Meanwhile, physicians will be perfectly justified in viewing with
suspicion all claims based on such conspicuously unscientific premises,
more especially so when these claims fail to find substantiation on
careful and painstaking analyses. In brief, whenever the physician
wishes to administer free iodin, Lugol’s solution (Liquor Iodi
Compositus, U. S. P., Physician’s Manual, page 84) is an inexpensive
and perfectly available preparation.--(_From the Journal A. M. A.,
March 28, 1908._)
“HYDROCYANATE OF IRON--TILDEN”
W. A. Puckner and W. S. Hilpert
Among the many inquiries received regarding the composition of secret
remedies was one in reference to “Hydrocyanate of Iron” manufactured by
the Tilden Company, New Lebanon, N. Y. This preparation is advertised
as being “unexcelled as a remedy for epilepsy, hysteria, chorea,
neurasthenia, locomotor ataxia, neuralgia, migraine, anemic headaches,
and all convulsive or reflex neuroses dependent on impairment of the
brain or spinal cord.” It is also said to be “valuable in uterine
reflex neuroses due to congestion; in amenorrhea due to anemia and
chlorosis and suppressed menstruation.”
The term “hydrocyanate of iron” is an unfamiliar one and is not found
in any available reference work on chemistry. Thinking that the term
might have been loosely applied to ferrocyanid of iron, or Prussian
blue (a compound once suggested for epilepsy, but long ago considered
useless), the correspondent wrote to the manufacturers asking if such
were the case. The Tilden Company answered:
“... our preparation Hydrocyanate of Iron is not Prussian blue in
any sense of the word. Prussian blue has no curative properties as
applied to all forms of epilepsy. Prussian blue is Ferrocyanid of
Iron while our preparation is Hydrocyanate of Iron.”
The only statements in the Tilden Company’s advertising matter
regarding the composition of hydrocyanate of iron are the following:
“Hydrocyanate of Iron (Tilden’s) is a correct and scientific
combination of well known principles.”
“Hydrocyanate of Iron (Tilden’s) combines well known properties of
ferruginous salts with the sedative action of Hydrocyanic acid.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account