The psycho-analytic study of the familyFlugel, J. C. (John Carl)
Science
The psycho-analytic study of the family
Flugel, J. C. (John Carl)
Families; Marriage; Parent and child; Psychoanalysis
There can be little doubt that much of the general resistance to, and
intolerance of, authority, that may be exhibited by certain individuals,
or at times by whole sections of a community (or even by whole peoples)
derives its motive power from a persistence in the Unconscious of parent
hatreds of this kind. A very considerable proportion of criminal actions
in the individual are also due to the same unconscious source, the still
existing desire to resist the authority of the parents finding outlet in a
displaced form in infringements of the laws, conventions, or regulations
imposed by the authority of society or of the State. Particularly
is this true of crimes against persons who embody or exercise this
authority--emperors, kings and other persons in high places, and it would
seem probable indeed that many cases of regicide or of attempts on the
lives of official personages have been committed by those suffering from
insufficiently controlled parent hatreds of unusual strength. Bearing in
mind the dangers that beset a community in which tendencies to anarchy,
lawlessness or unreasonable opposition to governmental authority are
widespread, it is obvious that the frequent occurrence of violent and
persistent parent hatreds in children, leading, as they so often do, to
displacements of this kind, is a matter of very serious sociological and
political importance[141].
[Sidenote: Displacements of respect and esteem]
These same persons in authority, who thus become the recipients displaced
enmity towards the parents, may however also serve in later life as
substitutes for those aspects of the parents in virtue of which these
latter were in childhood reverenced as the possessors of unlimited
power, wisdom, virtue or knowledge (_Cp._ above p. 54). Especially is
this the case perhaps with regard to ecclesiastical authorities; the
priest, as the interpreter of wisdom that transcends earthly knowledge
and the transmitter of commands that transcend earthly authority,
being peculiarly suitable as an object of this emotional attitude. The
head of the Roman Catholic Church has indeed, through the doctrine of
infallibility, been explicitly endowed (with reference to a certain sphere
of thought) with the character of perfect knowledge and perfect wisdom,
which the young child with the sense of its own immense inferiority in
these respects, is liable to attribute to its parents. The teacher too,
in his position of moral and intellectual authority, frequently becomes
the recipient of similar feelings; the additional influence which he
possesses over his pupils through the latter's childish over-estimation
of his knowledge and capacity often receiving frank acknowledgment in
the fact of his unwillingness ever to appear to have been mistaken or to
have been ignorant with regard to any matter, lest the realisation of his
fallibility should detract from the suggestive power that he has hitherto
enjoyed.
[Sidenote: Medical practitioners as parent-substitutes]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account